The Sources of <del>Soviet</del> Iranian Conduct: George Kennan’s Fifteen Lessons for Understanding and Dealing With Tehran

The Sources of Soviet Iranian Conduct: George Kennan’s Fifteen Lessons for Understanding and Dealing With Tehran

Karim Sadjadpour Policy Outlook December 9, 2010

Summary

While the Iranian government—an increasingly militarized theocracy—is unique, George Kennan’s 1947 essay, “The Sources of Soviet Conduct,” reveals instructive behavioral parallels between the Iranian and Soviet regimes.

Related Topics

Political Reform

Full Text

In an attempt to understand the Islamic Republic of Iran—a regime that has bedeviled the United States since the 1979 revolution—U.S. analysts often invoke three historical analogies, comparing Iran to Red China, Nazi Germany, and the Soviet Union. While the Iranian government—an increasingly militarized theocracy—is sui generis, former U.S. diplomat George Kennan’s 1947 essay, “The Sources of Soviet Conduct,” reveals instructive behavioral parallels between the Iranian and Soviet regimes. A close reading of Kennan’s analysis suggests some key lessons current U.S. policy makers should consider in dealing with Iran, including:

Iran’s revolutionaries are defined by what they are against, not what they are for, and rely on foreign threats to maintain their legitimacy. The Islamic Republic may make tactical offers of compromise, but its hostility toward the United States is strategic.
Given that Iran’s regional strength derives from its political influence more than its military prowess, U.S. strategy should focus less on containing Tehran militarily and more on political measures to diminish the regional appeal of Iran and its client militias including Hamas and Hizbollah.
While the ability of the United States to expedite positive political reform in Iran is limited, Washington can help constrain the Islamic Republic’s ability to repress and censor its population.

Kennan’s wisdom does not call on the United States to shun dialogue with Tehran, but merely to temper its expectations. Talking to Iran will not resolve the real, serious differences the United States has with the Islamic Republic, but given Iran’s influence on major U.S. foreign policy challenges—namely Iraq, Afghanistan, Arab-Israeli peace, terrorism, energy security, and nuclear proliferation—it can help mitigate the risk of escalation and misunderstanding.

In the process, Kennan would caution, the United States should remain “at all times cool and collected” until the Iranian regime is forced to change under the weight of its contradictions and economic malaise. “For no mystical, Messianic movement,” Kennan wrote in 1947, “can face frustration indefinitely without eventually adjusting itself one way or another to the logic of that state of affairs.”

Source: http://carnegieendowment.org/2010/12/09/sources-of-soviet-iranian-conduct-george-kennan-s-fifteen-lessons-for-understanding-and-dealing-with-tehran/1q9j

More from The Global Think Tank

Foreign Policy

The Sources of Iranian Conduct

Summary While no historical analogy is perfect, analysts looking to understand Iran’s character and predict its future trajectory can benefit from comparing the Islamic Republic to the Soviet Union. More >

The Wall Street Journal

Questions for Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

Summary During Iranian President Ahmadinejad’s visit to the U.N. General Assembly in New York, journalists will have the opportunity to confront him on human rights issues in Iran, the country’s internal politics, and the recent defections of Iranian senior diplomats. More >

Council on Foreign Relations

Containment Policy for a Nuclear Iran?

Summary The ideals espoused by the Green Movement in Iran continue to hold a strong appeal to the country’s youthful population, but the movement needs to explain to Iranian workers why it would govern better than the current regime if it wants to change the power dynamic in Iran. More >

September 21, 2010 Washington, D.C.

Let the Swords Encircle Me: A Journey Behind the Headlines of Iran

Summary Iran increasingly dominates international newspaper headlines and foreign policy agendas, but its people and regime remain poorly understood in the West. More >

June 8, 2010 Washington, D.C.

Taking Tehran’s Temperature: One Year On

Summary Last year’s highly controversial presidential election spurred Iran’s largest uprisings since the 1979 revolution. While the government gradually succeeded in violently quashing the opposition momentum, the country’s deep internal rifts remain visible. More >

Twitter

@CarnegieEndow

In Fact

70%

of oil consumed in the United States

is for the transportation sector.

20%

of Chechnya’s pre-1994 population

has fled to different parts of the world.

58%

of oil consumed in China

was from foreign sources in 2012.

million cases pending

in India’s judicial system.

million people killed

in Cold War conflicts.

18%

of the U.S. economy

is consumed by healthcare.

$536

billion in goods and services

traded between the United States and China in 2012.

$100

billion in foreign investment and oil revenue

have been lost by Iran because of its nuclear program.

4700%

increase in China’s GDP per capita

between 1972 and today.

$11

billion have been spent

to complete the Bushehr nuclear reactor in Iran.

of Iran’s electricity needs

is all the Bushehr nuclear reactor provides.

new airports

are set to be built in China by 2015.

journalists

were imprisoned in Turkey as of August 2012 according to the OSCE.

67%

of the world's population

will reside in cities by 2050.

million Russian citizens

are considered “ethnic Muslims.”

Stay in the Know

Enter your email address in the field below to receive the latest Carnegie analysis in your inbox!

Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

Regions

Countries

The Sources of Soviet Iranian Conduct: George Kennan’s Fifteen Lessons for Understanding and Dealing With Tehran

More from The Global Think Tank

The Sources of Iranian Conduct

Questions for Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

Containment Policy for a Nuclear Iran?

Let the Swords Encircle Me: A Journey Behind the Headlines of Iran

Taking Tehran’s Temperature: One Year On

Twitter

In Fact

Stay in the Know

Sada

Mudslinging in Morocco

Of Identities and Institutions

Morocco’s Salafis: In Search of a Comprehensive Solution

China’s Military and the U.S.-Japan Alliance in 2030: A Strategic Net Assessment Swaine, Paal

Egypt’s Dismal Opposition: A Second Look Carothers

Dead on Arrival Muasher

The Muslim Brotherhood Prepares for a Comeback in Syria

A New Saudi Arabia? Wehrey

Chinese Takeaway: Li in Pakistan

A New Saudi Arabia?

Why Libya’s ‘Isolation Law’ Threatens Progress

Prospects for Afghanistan’s 2014 Elections

The Prickly Politics of Aid

Accidental India: How the Shadow of Crisis Has Shaped a Nation

Economic Dimensions of U.S. Engagement with Southeast Asia

Institutional Reform in Libya, Egypt, and Tunisia

Varieties of Democracy: Global Standards, Local Knowledge