Proliferation News
» June 23, 2011

A Criteria-Based Approach to Nuclear Cooperation With Pakistan

Toby Dalton, Mark Hibbs and George Perkovich | Carnegie Policy Outlook


In the wake of the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Beijing decided to review its plans for expanding nuclear power in China. It appears likely that China will shift its ambitious nuclear construction program away from older designs to modern technology provided by foreign vendors. Although there are no indications that China is reconsidering its decision to build two additional nuclear power reactors in Pakistan—which are based on technology Beijing will probably abandon domestically—the accident in Japan provides Beijing with an opportunity to pause and contemplate conditioning its cooperation with Pakistan on improvements in nuclear safety and security.

During such a pause, Beijing could consider the possibility of developing within the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) a criteria-based approach to nuclear cooperation with states lacking full-scope safeguards (FSS). This strategy would be invoked irrespective of other discussions about future NSG membership and criteria that might be considered in that context. A criteria-based approach would provide a roadmap for states without FSS, including Pakistan, to qualify for civil nuclear cooperation, thus placing China's current and future nuclear cooperation with Pakistan in an NSG process.

The lynchpin in this approach is incentivizing China through the licensing of foreign reactor technology, so that China sees greater economic potential in achieving its longer-term ambition of becoming a nuclear exporter than in its shorter-term deals with Pakistan. Such an approach could help resolve persistent questions about the NSG's future, which were raised by the U.S.-India nuclear deal and by Russia's previous nuclear commerce with India. This strategy thus has the potential to resolve this issue in a way that strengthens the NSG, provides China with incentives to reconsider its cooperation with Pakistan, and gives Pakistan the international legitimacy it desperately seeks. Full Article   

Follow the Nuclear Policy Program
RSS News Feed Twitter
Footer information begins here

More from Proliferation News

David Albright and Andrea Stricker | ISIS
On June 21, Iran's atomic energy chief, Fereydoun Abbasi-Davani, in a speech to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) conference on nuclear safety in Vienna, held to review safety standards in the wake of the Fukushima disaster, indicated that Iran is in no hurry to join the international Convention on Nuclear Safety. Abbasi-Davani said that Iran has started the process of ratifying the pact, but that it would first need to consider whether or not it conflicts with its rights. Iran is the sole country with a significant nuclear power program that has not signed the 1994 convention.     Full Article

Asahi Shimbun
A troubled water purification system at the Fukushima No. 1 nuclear power plant has processed about 1,825 tons of radioactive water, Tokyo Electric Power Co. said on June 22. A series of malfunctions have plagued the system since it was installed at the start of June, but TEPCO said continued testing of the equipment had brought radiation levels in the processed water to about 1/100,000th of original levels. The total volume of contaminated water on the plant's site has been reduced.     Full Article

Elaine M. Grossman | Global Security Newswire
The U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee last week issued new legislation that echoes questions about President Obama's nuclear weapons strategy initially raised last month in the House. The fiscal 2012 defense authorization bill approved unanimously by the panel calls for a presidential report "describing any new nuclear employment strategy if and when such a strategy is issued," according to a Senate committee release.     Full Article

IWorld Nuclear News
The UK's finalised Energy National Policy Statements (NPS), which set the stage for planning decisions on energy infrastructure projects including nuclear, have been formally published ready for debate in parliament.The publication of the NPSs is the culmination of a process that began with a consultation on six draft statements for energy infrastructure, which ran from November 2009 to February 2010. A formal response had been expected later that year but following UK general elections in May 2010 the country's coalition government subsequently decided to launch a further consultation in October 2010. The relaunched consultation closed on 24 January 2011 after receiving over two and a half thousand responses.     Full Article

Global Security Newswire
Russia on Tuesday voiced objection to the presence of a U.S. warship equipped with ballistic missile defense technology in neighboring Georgia, saying the matter undermined the diplomatic "reset" between the two former Cold War opponents, Agence France-Presse reported. The USS Monterey docked at a Georgian port in order to take part in three-day training event with local coast guards. The Aegis-equipped naval cruiser is deployed to Europe as part of of the Obama administration's "phased adaptive approach" to European missile defense. Russia has questioned why the warship is in the Black Sea if missile attacks are feared from the Middle East, further south.     Full Article

Footer information begins here

Carnegie Resources

Browse     Issues     Regions     Programs     Experts     Events     Publications

Multilingual Content     Русский     中文     عربي

Global Centers     Washington DC     Moscow     Beijing     Beirut     Brussels

Follow Carnegie
RSS News Feeds Facebook Twitter YouTube Scribd

About Proliferation News

Produced twice weekly, Proliferation News provides a free summary of news and analysis on efforts to prevent the spread and use of nuclear weapons. Visit the Carnegie Nuclear Policy Program website for further information and resources. Please send your comments and suggestions to the editor at

About the Carnegie Nuclear Policy Program

The Carnegie Nuclear Policy Program is an internationally acclaimed source of expertise and policy thinking on nuclear industry, nonproliferation, security, and disarmament. Its multinational staff stays at the forefront of nuclear policy issues in the United States, Russia, China, Northeast Asia, South Asia, and the Middle East.

About the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is a private, nonprofit organization dedicated to advancing cooperation between nations and promoting active international engagement by the United States. Founded in 1910, its work is nonpartisan and dedicated to achieving practical results.

As it celebrates its Centennial, the Carnegie Endowment is pioneering the first global think tank, with offices now in Washington, Moscow, Beijing, Beirut, and Brussels. These five locations include the centers of world governance and the places whose political evolution and international policies will most determine the near-term possibilities for international peace and economic advance.

If you would no longer like to receive Proliferation News, please click here to unsubscribe.

Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

1779 Massachusetts Ave, NW, Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202 483 7600  |  Fax: 202 483 1840  |  Email: