- +2
Judy Dempsey, Alexander Gabuev, Rose Gottemoeller, …
{
"authors": [
"Rose Gottemoeller"
],
"type": "legacyinthemedia",
"centerAffiliationAll": "dc",
"centers": [
"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace"
],
"collections": [
"Korean Peninsula"
],
"englishNewsletterAll": "ctw",
"nonEnglishNewsletterAll": "",
"primaryCenter": "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace",
"programAffiliation": "russia",
"programs": [
"Russia and Eurasia",
"Nuclear Policy"
],
"projects": [],
"regions": [
"Middle East",
"Iran",
"South Korea",
"Caucasus",
"Russia"
],
"topics": [
"Foreign Policy",
"Nuclear Policy"
]
}REQUIRED IMAGE
US-Russia: Holding the line against nukes
Source: International Herald Tribune
MOSCOW Iran has answered its opponents at the negotiating table, and a clever answer it is. In June, the five permanent members of the UN Security Council plus Germany proposed a package of incentives to Iran, but they also warned of sanctions if Tehran did not agree to suspend uranium enrichment. The Iranians have come back sounding eminently reasonable, requesting an immediate return to "serious talks" - but they also have said nothing about suspending enrichment.
So the "five-plus-one" team now faces a serious challenge: Can the coalition hold together to implement sanctions against Iran when it fails to suspend enrichment on Aug. 31? Russia and the United States have had very different views of the effectiveness of sanctions, and Iran seems intent on splitting these two strong countries apart.
The issue becomes more urgent with the reality that sooner or later, the United States, Russia and their partners are bound to sit down again with North Korea, the other country threatening damage to the nonproliferation regime.
On the face of it, Russia and the United States have a history that will help them. They have been leaders in preventing nuclear proliferation since they joined forces to negotiate the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty in the 1960s. As the two largest nuclear weapon states, they have had a special responsibility to lead by example - reducing their own arsenals - as well as preventing the further spread of nuclear weapons.
In the past decade, Moscow and Washington have often fallen down on the first task by failing to negotiate new reductions in nuclear weapons. They have, however, succeeded in reducing nuclear potential. Alone and in concert, they have closed down or shrunk key weapons-production facilities and disposed of tons of weapons-useable nuclear material.
The United States and Russia are accustomed to working together to solve tough proliferation problems. Cooperation in this area is vulnerable, though, when attention in both capitals swings to the latest dire crises, as it has today to the Iran nuclear program. Joint programs that are vital to reducing nuclear weapons potential begin to sink into the swamps of politics and bureaucracy. Two programs are in this fix today - one to dispose of weapons plutonium, the other to prevent more plutonium from being produced.
In the 1990s, the United States and Russia agreed to cooperate on these tasks, vital to slashing their potential to produce new nuclear weapons. Today, Washington and Moscow are working together to shut down Russia's plutonium-production reactors. The United States is bearing a significant share of the cost of the project and is closely involved in design and construction.
And both Russia and the United States are ramping up efforts to dispose of weapons plutonium.
Sadly, this new momentum may be stalling. The U.S. Congress has taken notice of past problems with the programs, and has decided to cut their funding for 2007. The Senate cut $206 million from the program to replace the plutonium reactors, saying that Russia with its oil wealth should now be able to contribute more for the program. The House of Representatives has cut funding from the program to destroy plutonium, arguing that the two countries can't even agree on the technical details of how to go about it, much less figure out how to pay for it all.
Both arguments have some truth to them, but they could not come at a worse time. If the United States and Russia lose their close cooperation on weapons plutonium, they will severely undermine the basis for their joint fight against nuclear proliferation.
President George W. Bush and President Vladmir Putin of Russia will have to refocus their attention on these problems. The experts should be able to agree on the technical options for dealing with plutonium, and what each will cost. With Putin's urging, the Russians could see their way clear to making a bigger contribution to these joint programs.
If the plutonium programs are killed in Congress, then Moscow and Washington will have lost a big battle in the fight against nuclear proliferation. And when the negotiating game gets tough, they may even find that they no longer have the joint will to counter the nuclear ambitions of Iran and North Korea.
Rose Gottemoeller is the director of the Carnegie Moscow Center. She was assistant U.S. secretary of energy responsible for nonproliferation programs during the Clinton administration.
Originally published in the International Herald Tribune.
About the Author
Nonresident Senior Fellow, Nuclear Policy Program
Rose Gottemoeller is a nonresident senior fellow in Carnegie’s Nuclear Policy Program. She also serves as lecturer at Stanford University’s Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies and is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution. Ambassador Gottemoeller served as the deputy secretary general of NATO from 2016 to 2019.
- The Spectacular Rise of the “Bad Boys” of NATO During the Ukraine CrisisQ&A
Recent Work
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.
More Work from Carnegie China
- Can China Turn Its Small Modular Reactor Ambitions into Commercial Reality?Article
China has showcased its engineering prowess with small modular reactor demonstration projects. But turning these technological achievements into commercial success will be a greater challenge.
Tong Zhao
- Untangling the Nuclear Knot: A Constructive Agenda for Managing China’s Nuclear Relations with the United States and Its AlliesPaper
The nuclear relationship between China and the United States is increasingly shaped by widening perception gaps rather than deliberate strategic design.
Tong Zhao
- Trump and Xi Are Angling for Three Years of StabilityCommentary
But their "principal to principal" model will only be as effective as the political strength of each leader back home.
Damien Ma
- China Sells Stability Amid American VolatilityCommentary
U.S. unpredictability has allowed China to capitalize on its positioning as the “responsible great power”. Paradoxically, the more China wins the perception game, the more likely expectations will rise for Beijing to deliver not just words but to demonstrate with its deeds.
Chong Ja Ian
- Why Vietnam Is Swinging in China’s DirectionCommentary
Hanoi and Beijing have long treated each other as distant cousins rather than comrades in arms. That might be changing as both sides draw closer to hedge against uncertainty and America’s erratic behavior.
Nguyễn Khắc Giang