• Research
  • Strategic Europe
  • About
  • Experts
Carnegie Europe logoCarnegie lettermark logo
EUNATO
  • Donate
{
  "authors": [
    "Judy Dempsey"
  ],
  "type": "commentary",
  "blog": "Strategic Europe",
  "centerAffiliationAll": "",
  "centers": [
    "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace",
    "Carnegie Europe"
  ],
  "collections": [],
  "englishNewsletterAll": "",
  "nonEnglishNewsletterAll": "",
  "primaryCenter": "Carnegie Europe",
  "programAffiliation": "",
  "programs": [],
  "projects": [],
  "regions": [
    "Russia"
  ],
  "topics": [
    "EU"
  ]
}
Strategic Europe logo

Source: Getty

Commentary
Strategic Europe

Putin, Power, and Punk

The trial of three young women in Moscow demonstrates that, despite the trappings of power, Vladimir Putin seems to be highly insecure.

Link Copied
By Judy Dempsey
Published on Aug 9, 2012
Strategic Europe

Blog

Strategic Europe

Strategic Europe offers insightful analysis, fresh commentary, and concrete policy recommendations from some of Europe’s keenest international affairs observers.

Learn More

What is the European Union going to do about Russia?

It’s a question that keeps popping up because Brussels has no strategy about how to deal with President Vladimir Putin or react to the kind of political and economic system he has established.

This question is becoming more relevant in the light of the trial of three young women – Maria Alyokhina, Yekaterina Samutsevich and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova who belong to the Pussy Riot punk band.

Over the past few days, the women have been sitting in a glass and metal cage in a crowded and often raucous Moscow court.

The three are being charged with “hooliganism motivated by religious hatred” after they had gone into the Christ the Savior Cathedral in Moscow last February and sang a song urging the Virgin Mary to rid Russia of Putin.

The charges carry a maximum seven-year prison term. A Russian state prosecutor this week demanded a three-year sentence.

You would think that under normal circumstances, the song would have created a bit of a rumpus from the Russian Orthodox Church authorities and then been forgotten. But no. The authorities have chosen to go on the offensive by putting the three singers on trial.

It says a lot about Putin.

Despite the trappings of power, Putin seems to be highly insecure.

Neither his control over the internal security services, his success at clamping down on the media, his control over television nor his bid to control the foreign non-governmental organizations have changed that.

Putin could simply have ignored Pussy Riot. Instead, he made an example of the band, pandering to the sentiments of what is still a very conservative society.

He may also have reckoned that the band should be made an example of, given how more and more Russians are fed up with Putin, according to Levada, the respected Russian opinion pollsters. Russians are now prepared to take to the streets, as confirmed by huge demonstrations that took place earlier this year in Moscow and other cities.

Whatever Putin’s motive, the trial is one more example of how frightened leaders become when artists mock or challenge them. The wise course would nearly always be to ignore them. Instead, leaders resort to hounding their critics.

It is exactly what happened to the Plastic People of the Universe.

The rock band, inspired by Frank Zappa and others, was founded in what was then Czechoslovakia, just days after Soviet tanks had rolled into the country to crush the 1968 Prague Spring.

The band was forced to go underground when the regime began banning its concerts and arresting its members.

In 1976, several of the Plastic People were put on trial, charged with “organized disturbance of the peace”. They were given prison sentences of between 8 and 18 months (lenient compared to the three years being demanded for Pussy Riot).

Instead of silencing the Plastic People of the Universe, the trial and sentencing emboldened the band. It continued singing in the underground—in woods and barns—attracting thousands of supporters. It didn’t matter if the regime kept detaining it’s members and supporters. The Plastic People of the Universe became an alternative to the philistine state culture. Only after the 1989 Velvet Revolution could the band sing freely.

Over twenty years later, Alexander Lukashenko, Belarus’s president and dubbed Europe’s last dictator, is also taking few risks when it comes to popular music.

He keeps a firm grim on the country’s musical scene, especially on bands such as N.R.M.

N.R.M. went through a very bad patch in 2005 when it was banned from playing on state-controlled radio and television and from performing publicly. In Belarus there are, of course, hardly any private radio stations that they could have gone to.

Occasionally, the band changed its name so as to be heard on the state channels. The rest of the time, it played in private homes.

N.R.M. has a huge following, which may explain why the regime will now allow it give concerts again rather than create an underground of supporters. But its access to FM radio is unofficially banned.

Of course, the European Union deplores what is happening in Belarus, just as it is deeply concerned about events at Moscow’s Khamovnichesky court.

A spokesman for Catherine Ashton, the EU’s foreign policy chief, said the EU was worried about the irregularities of the case and the intimidation of lawyers and journalists.

But the truth is that there is not much that Ashton can do, given that there is no unity among the 27 member states about how to deal with Putin’s Russia. But disunity can always be used as an excuse not to ask tough questions about how Europe should deal with Putin’s Russia.

How did Nadezhda Tolokonnikova put it in her said closing defendant’s speech this Wednesday?

"This is a trial of the whole government system of Russia, which so likes to show its harshness toward the individual, its indifference to his honor and dignity,” she said. “If this political system throws itself against three girls … it shows this political system is afraid of truth."

About the Author

Judy Dempsey

Nonresident Senior Fellow, Carnegie Europe

Judy Dempsey is a nonresident senior fellow at Carnegie Europe

    Recent Work

  • Commentary
    Europe Needs to Hear What America is Saying

      Judy Dempsey

  • Commentary
    Babiš’s Victory in Czechia Is Not a Turning Point for European Populists

      Judy Dempsey

Judy Dempsey
Nonresident Senior Fellow, Carnegie Europe
Judy Dempsey
EURussia

Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.

More Work from Strategic Europe

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    There Is No Shortcut for Europe in Armenia

    Europe has an interest in supporting Armenian leader Nikol Pashinyan as he tries to make peace with neighbors and loosen ties with Russia. But it is depersonalized support in the long term, not quickfire flash, that will win the day.

      Thomas de Waal

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    The EU Equivocating on Turkey Is Bad Geopolitics

    Following Ursula von der Leyen’s gaffe equating Turkey to Russia and China, relations with Ankara risk deteriorating even further. Without better, more consistent diplomatic messaging, how can the EU pretend to be a geopolitical power?

      Sinan Ülgen

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    Taking the Pulse: Is the EU Ready for Rapprochement With the UK?

    Closer EU-UK ties could help address urgent European concerns. But is the EU ready for rapprochement with the United Kingdom?

      • Rym Momtaz

      Rym Momtaz, ed.

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    France, Italy, and Spain Should Use Force in Lebanon

    Europe has been standing by while its Southern neighborhood is being redrawn by force. To establish a path to peace between Israel and Lebanon, it’s time for Europeans to get involved with hard power.

      • Rym Momtaz

      Rym Momtaz

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    The Fog of AI War

    In Ukraine, Gaza, and Iran, AI warfare has come to dominate, with barely any oversight or accountability. Europe must lead the charge on the responsible use of new military technologies.

      Raluca Csernatoni

Get more news and analysis from
Carnegie Europe
Carnegie Europe logo, white
Rue du Congrès, 151000 Brussels, Belgium
  • Research
  • Strategic Europe
  • About
  • Experts
  • Projects
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Careers
  • Privacy
  • For Media
  • Gender Equality Plan
Get more news and analysis from
Carnegie Europe
© 2026 Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. All rights reserved.