Commentary
Judy Dempsey
{
"authors": [
"Judy Dempsey"
],
"type": "commentary",
"blog": "Strategic Europe",
"centerAffiliationAll": "",
"centers": [
"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace",
"Carnegie Europe"
],
"collections": [
"Transatlantic Cooperation"
],
"englishNewsletterAll": "",
"nonEnglishNewsletterAll": "",
"primaryCenter": "Carnegie Europe",
"programAffiliation": "",
"programs": [],
"projects": [],
"regions": [
"Middle East",
"Asia",
"Russia",
"Europe",
"North America",
"Western Europe"
],
"topics": [
"Security"
]
}
Source: Getty
Commentary
Judy Asks: Is the West Up to the Job?
Diplomats, parliamentarians, and experts at the 2019 Munich Security Conference weigh in on the future of global leadership.
By Judy Dempsey
Published on Feb 17, 2019
Carnegie Europe was on the ground at the 2019 Munich Security Conference, offering readers exclusive access to the debates as they unfold and providing insights on today’s immense threats to international peace and stability.
***
Each year at the Munich Security Conference, I ask a topical question to a random selection of participants. They are asked to answer in about ten words. Answers are listed in the order of who responded first. A big thanks to everyone who responded as they scuttled between panels and meetings.
Nikola DimitrovMinister of Foreign Affairs, Republic of North Macedonia
For the West to do the job, it has to start to think big again.
Elmar BrokChair of the European Parliament Committee on Foreign Affairs
The West does not exist anymore as a strategic community because of Trump’s policies.
Linas LinkevičiusMinister of Foreign Affairs, Lithuania
We could be.
Javier SolanaFormer EU High Representative for Foreign and Security Policy, Secretary-General of NATO, and Foreign Minister of Spain
It is not totally up to the job. We don’t have the people to take that responsibility.
Carlos PascualSenior Vice President, Global Energy, IHS Markit
Our leadership is fractured and reaction has overtaken vision
Cem ÖzdemirMember of the German Bundestag Alliance '90/The Greens and Chairman of the German Parliament’s Transport and Digital Infrastructure Committee
It has to be. There is no option. Otherwise the gap will be filled by Moscow and Beijing.
Carl BildtFormer Swedish Foreign Minister
I’m not quite certain what the West is. The EU has yet to make itself into a power of relevance.
Kenneth RothExecutive Director, Human Rights Watch
Yes, with non-traditional leaders. Coalitions of smaller and medium size countries have filled the leadership gap.
Barbara WiessallaGeneral Director for Infrastructure, Environmental Protection Service, German Defense Ministry
Of course.
Eva-Maria KernProfessor, Bundeswehr University Munich
We must be careful not to lose the best heads.
Michael McFaulFormer U.S. Ambassador to Moscow and Professor at Stanford University
It depends on how you define the West. I’m a long-term optimist but a short-term pessimist about the future of the West.
Stefanie BabstHead of Strategic Analysis Capability, NATO
We can try hard. But I’m not sure we are confident enough about ourselves.
Rose GottemoellerDeputy Secretary General, NATO
Yes. NATO’s up to the job.
Deidre BergerDirector, American Jewish Committee
It’s an open question that is unexpected, and that’s what’s frightening.
Almut Wieland-KarimiExecutive Director, Center for International Peace Operations (ZIF)
We could be up to the job. We know what is wrong. But it takes big leadership.
Franziska BrantnerGreen Party Spokesperson, German Parliament’s Committee on European Union Affairs
No. It’s struggling to deal with the challenges together.
David MilibandPresident and Chief Executive Officer, International Rescue Committee
Yes. We have the right values that this world needs more and more.
Nora MüllerExecutive Director of International Affairs, Körber-Stiftung
In principle yes, if it succeeds in overcoming internal divisions.
John KerryFormer U.S Secretary of State and Visiting Distinguished Statesman at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Totally. 100 percent. If the job is living up to NATO and Article 5, the answer is yes. To fulfill the full transatlantic alliance, we need a new president.
Florence GaubDeputy Director, European Union Institute for Security Studies
Yes, if we stop being ashamed of who we are and what we stand for.
Sauli NiinistöPresident of Finland
We are living in confusing times, not only in the West but globally. Are we facing the end of diplomacy? That is something we should never see.
Katinka BaryschGroup Strategy and Portfolio Manager, Allianz
No. After globalization, the West by itself can never do the job of fixing the post-1945 era.
Aleksey PushkovChairman of the Commission on Information and Media, Council of Federation, Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation
I don’t think so. I think the West is carried away by its own agenda. It fails to see the agenda of others.
Ian BremmerPresident and Founder, Eurasia Group
If the job is a U.S.-led global order, no.
Mamuka BakhtadzePrime Minister of Georgia
If the job is to support free nations and is value-driven, yes.
Daniela SchwarzerDirector, German Council on Foreign Relations
We still don’t want to realize what we have to offer and what we have to lose.
Gwendolyn SasseDirector, Centre for East European and International Studies (ZOiS)
Only if the “West” (EU, U.S., NATO) is rebuilt.
Senior Iranian Foreign Ministry Diplomat Who Asked to Remain Anonymous
No. Because of double standards, normative arrogance, and demagogic politicians.
Image source: MSC / Kuhlmann
About the Author
Judy Dempsey
Nonresident Senior Fellow, Carnegie Europe
Judy Dempsey is a nonresident senior fellow at Carnegie Europe
- Germany’s Shattered Consensus
- Europe Needs to Hear What America is SayingCommentary
Judy Dempsey
Recent Work
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.
More Work from Strategic Europe
- Taking the Pulse: Does the EU Have a Germany Problem?Commentary
Are Germany’s economic, industrial, and political struggles becoming a liability for the EU’s ability to rise to the geopolitical moment?
Rym Momtaz, ed.
- The Speech Ursula von der Leyen Can’t DeliverCommentary
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is about to give her annual address on the state of the EU. Here’s what she won’t—but should—say.
Rym Momtaz
- Europe Fails to Learn the Lessons from CeutaCommentary
The aftermath of the Ceuta crisis shows Europe has drawn the wrong lessons. Rather than doubling down on failed migration policies, the EU needs to address the underlying roots of such episodes.
Richard Youngs
- Germany’s Shattered ConsensusCommentary
An overwhelming victory by a far-right-wing party in a small state in eastern Germany will have major repercussions for Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s coalition.
Judy Dempsey
- Taking the Pulse: Is Canada Leading a Third Way?Commentary
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has twice inspired praise for standing up to U.S. President Donald Trump: at the 2026 World Economic Forum in Davos and on Canada-U.S. trade negotiations. Is Carney showing a third way better than the EU has in dealing with the Trump administration?
Rym Momtaz, ed.
