in the media

Curious Case of Missing Iranian Scientist

Although Iranian scientist Shahram Amiri has told conflicting stories regarding the nature of his time in the United States, his defection represents the growing dissatisfaction of the Iranian people towards the regime.

published by
CBS News
 on July 14, 2010

Source: CBS News

Iranian scientist Shahram Amiri, who defected to the United States to provide information on the Iranian nuclear program, has recently alleged that he was kidnapped and tortured by the CIA. However, notes Karim Sadjadpour, “this narrative is undermined by that fact that Amiri was posting YouTube videos while he was ostensibly in CIA detention.” Amiri has also released a contradictory video where he suggested that he was actually in the United States to pursue his studies. Sadjadpour believes that Amiri choose to allege kidnapping and torture against the CIA to help the Iranian government save face. Amiri had been living in the United States for a year, while his wife and child were still in Iran under extreme pressure from the regime. Ultimately, Sadjadpour concludes, the primary factor for his return was due to this pressure on his family.

It is doubtful that Amiri was a major player in the Iranian nuclear program and he undoubtedly had no decision-making role. According to Sadjadpour, “the Iranian nuclear program is very compartmentalized” and this isolates people like Amiri from divulging much information. Yet Amiri’s defection does have significance. He represents the growing disaffection that Iranians feel with the regime. “There are thousands of people like Amiri that could be lured to outside,” notes Sadjadpour. 

 
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.