Edition

A Criteria-based Approach for Non-NPT States' NSG Membership

IN THIS ISSUE: A criteria-based approach to NSG membership, China considers Iranian invitation to nuclear facilities, Tepco admits two more meltdowns, German industry backs abolishing nuclear power, coming clean about nuclear power, diplomats expect stronger IAEA stance on Syria.

Published on May 24, 2011
 

NSG Membership: A Criteria-Based Approach for Non-NPT States

Pierre Goldschmidt | Proliferation Analysis

India Jaitapur

In 2008, the 46 participating governments of the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) agreed to exempt India from the comprehensive IAEA safeguards requirement of the NSG Guidelines. This "India exemption" permits suppliers to conduct civil nuclear trade with India, one of the three states that never joined the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).
The nuclear policy community widely believes this exemption undermines the credibility of the global nuclear nonproliferation regime. The desirability of providing access to the safest and most efficient nuclear power technology to produce electricity while protecting the environment, even to non-NPT states, is perfectly understandable, even though such supply is contrary to both the spirit of the NPT bargain (as it is presently understood) and the letter of the NSG Guidelines. In agreeing to export nuclear items and technologies to India, the NSG should have required India to accept formally at least the obligations of the five nuclear-weapon states recognized under the NPT. The NSG also should have entitled India to less cooperation from the supplier states than that made available to NPT non-nuclear-weapon states (NNWS). Instead, the NSG exemption failed to commit India to a responsible nonproliferation policy. Full Article   



Follow the Nuclear Policy Program
 RSS News Feed Twitter
Footer information begins here

More from Proliferation News


 
 
Chris Buckley | Reuters
China said on Tuesday it will consider Iran's invitation to send experts to see its disputed nuclear facilities, made during talks with Iran's foreign minister that a Chinese spokeswoman said covered strengthening bilateral ties.     Full Article

Kazuaki Nagata and Masami Ito | The Japan Times
Tokyo Electric Power Co. admitted Tuesday what many experts had long suspected: The cores of reactors 2 and 3 at the Fukushima No. 1 nuclear plant likely melted down and dropped to the bottom of their pressure vessels, just as happened at unit 1.     Full Article

Washington Post
Germany's most powerful industrial sectors said Tuesday they are backing government plans to abolish nuclear power within about a decade, but warn that blackouts and other risks could arise from the decision.     Full Article

Scientific American
Ever since Japan's battered Fukushima Daiichi reactor complex began emitting radiation in March, calls to abandon nuclear power have risen in the U.S. and Germany, among other countries. If only it were so simple.     Full Article

 
 
Related Fact Sheet
Global Security Newswire
Diplomats expect the International Atomic Energy Agency to adopt stronger wording in an upcoming assessment to suggest Syria was constructing an undisclosed nuclear reactor inside a facility destroyed in a 2007 Israeli airstrike, Reuters reported on Monday.     Full Article
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.