A Tripoli wall alive with opposing graffiti. “Fajr Libya, Allahu Akbar, like it or not,” has been written in red but everything apart from Allahu Akbar has been crossed out with black. In green is written: “God, the Prophet, Libya,” and in yellow: “Long live Free Libya. Forever. With my regards,” signed off with an illegible name. Further down the wall are multiple crossings out of both “Karama” and “Fajr Libya.” Photo by Tom Westcott

 

">“Fajr Libya + Kaswara = Daash. Karama = the Libyan Army.” The writer of this graffiti has accused Fajr Libya, which controls the capital, of being aligned with the Islamic State, and aligned the military operation Karama with the Libyan National Army based in the east of the country. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“Yes to Kaswara, Libya’s Revolutionaries.” Kaswara, another name for Fajr Libya, presents itself as the protector of the 2011 Revolution, saying its armies comprise former revolutionaries and accusing government forces of being pro-Qaddafi. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“Yes to Libya’s revolutionaries.” Another piece of graffiti supporting Fajr Libya, which depicts its army as being comprised of fighters from the 2011 revolution. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

Graffiti written either side of a poster showing seven young men killed in the 2011 revolution. “Yes to Bukhamada. God make Haftar victorious.” (Wanis Bukhmada is the commander of the Benghazi Special Forces and Khalifa Haftar leads Operation Karama, both of which are fighting under the Libyan National Army in Benghazi.) Opposing red graffiti states, “No to Karama. Yes to Fajr Libya.” Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“No, no to the House of Representatives in Tobruk.” This anti-Karama statement opposes the internationally-recognized parliament, the legality of which was undermined by a recent ruling by the Supreme Court. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

Pro-Karama graffiti against the General National Congress (GNC) in Tripoli, referring to its extension after its mandate expired on February 7, 2014. “Down with the General (Non-)National Congress, Qaddafi’s students. No to the extension,” is written in red. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“Karama" and “Misrati” spray-painted in black and crossed out with red paint (some of the armed forces under Fajr Libya are from the city of Misrata). “Allahu Akbar” is added beneath in red. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“No, no to Ansar al-Sharia, yes to the army and police.” The words “no” have been semi-obliterated with yellow paint to reverse the meaning, over which the words “no” have been resprayed. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“Zintan. Yes to Karama. Operation Volcano.” This graffiti names an offensive in the Western Mountains by the Libyan National Army and forces from Zintan. “We won’t forget the Ghargour martyrs,” add the words in red, referring to an incident in November 2013 when members of armed groups from Misrata opened fire on a peaceful protest in Tripoli’s Ghargour area of Tripoli, killing more than 40 people and injuring over 400. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“To hell with you all.” The writer of this graffiti does not appear to support either side in Libya’s conflict, using a phrase employed by Qaddafi during some of his televised speeches in the revolution. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

“Death has come to you. If you are truly Tripolitanian, you wouldn’t take any side.” This alludes to the fight for Tripoli International Airport between rival armed groups from the city of Misrata and town of Zintan, which paved the way for Fajr Libya to take control of the capital. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

Graffiti that does not appear to be aligned with either side, reading: “We won’t go back to being in chains” [on the right] and “February 17 was not just a revolution” [on the left]. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

A representation of national hero Omar Mukhtar, who led the Libyan resistance movement against Italian colonialism. Since the 2011 revolution, he has become a popular subject for graffiti art around the capital. Photo by Tom Westcott

 

Painted in the shades of the Libyan flag, this colourful eagle seems to evoke the 2011 revolution when, in the name of freedom, the Libyan people united to overthrow Muammar Qaddafi. Photo by Tom Westcott

Tripoli remains almost eerily quiet as Libya’s civil war rages on in much of the country. But short rants—sometimes misspelled, bearing all the hallmarks of having been sprayed hastily—cover the capital’s walls, which are alive with political comment. They spill across surfaces, occasionally seeping into the murals that appeared after the 2011 revolution, including carefully executed renditions of national hero Omar Mukhtar and caricatures of the country’s former dictator, Muammar al-Qaddafi. These words tell a story of political leanings and ideological beliefs in a country where some have once again become cautious to speak their minds. They also show the country’s shifting politics, charting the unfolding civil war, which has pitted friends against each other, resurrected old tribal allegiances, and forged new partnerships while fracturing old alliances.

This is played out on the side of one small abandoned building in a central Tripoli district. Words sprayed in black and red pledge allegiance to rival governments. Between them, a large poster propped up against the wall bears photos of seven young men killed during the 2011 revolution. The poster depicts a country that united in revolutionary spirit almost four years ago to overthrow Qaddafi. But the spray-painted words suggest Libya is now rife with divisions.

The layering of Tripoli’s recent graffiti—with names crossed through and new allegiances sprayed above or below the original words—mirrors the political divisions. The country has two governments, two parliaments, and even two armies. Both armies are fighting several conflicts—ideological in some areas and political or tribal in others—that comprise Libya’s fractured civil war. For the capital’s graffiti commentators, the names of warring sides are the main focus. Operations Kaswara and Fajr (Dawn) took control of the Tripoli International Airport and the capital itself. They have become synonymous with the Tripoli-based government installed in August by the former Libyan parliament, the General National Congress (GNC). Operation Karama (Dignity) is the name of a military campaign launched by General Khalifa Haftar to wrest control of the eastern city of Benghazi from extremist armed groups. The word has come to represent Libya’s internationally recognized government in Beida and parliament—the House of Representatives (HoR)—in Tobruk. Although Operation Karama was originally condemned by Libya’s official institutions, in November it was sanctioned by the HoR and brought under the Libyan National Army’s control.

“Now you can tell which areas are with Karama by the graffiti,” explained Musbah, a taxi driver. “But it is complicated because some who are against Fajr Libya do not necessarily support Haftar.” Other people, he said, are tired of the instability and political infighting that have characterized post-revolutionary Libya and do not support either side. “To hell with you all,” reads one graffito, echoing words Qaddafi aimed at the international community in one of his televised statements during the revolution. Another tag cautions “real Tripolitanians” against taking any sides. “Death has come to you,” it warns, referring to the battle last summer between armed groups from the city of Misrata and the mountain town of Zintan for control of Tripoli’s international airport. (The clashes left the airport destroyed and paved the way for Fajr Libya to enter the capital.)

Although Fajr Libya is already established in Tripoli and controls key Libyan institutions there, it is now struggling to gain international recognition, even though a recent ruling by the Supreme Court undermined the legitimacy of the HoR, which affiliated with its Karama rival. Despite attempts to lure embassies and companies back with reassurances that the capital is safe, the Italian and Hungarian embassies are the only European countries with a remaining diplomatic presence. The U.S. and British embassies have relocated to Malta and neighboring Tunisia, respectively. Neither shows any imminent plan to return. “Like other embassies which left Tripoli last summer, we continue to have serious concerns about the current unstable security situation,” said Michael Aron, British Ambassador to Libya. “The fact that we do not recognize the ‘Government’ in Tripoli or the GNC is an additional factor.”¹

While the capital is undoubtedly calm, with scarcely any visible armed presence on the streets, some residents point out that quiet doesn’t necessarily promise security. “Tripoli is safe, as long as you don’t say anything against the government here,” said Mohammed, a former journalist who stopped working as a reporter because it had become too high-risk. He added that many of his colleagues had fled the country after being threatened or intimidated in the first months of Fajr Libya’s presence in Tripoli. The press freedom NGO Reporters Without Borders (RWB) has documented seven murders, 37 abductions, and 127 acts of harassment or physical violence against journalists since the 2011 revolution. “Covering the ongoing turmoil or even just describing a particular faction’s military progress or political position exposes journalists to great danger. Carrying a camera or a press card now requires considerable courage,” RWB said in an October post. Yet Fajr Libya insists that the situation has now changed. “Some journalists were jailed and others ran away because they were part of media militias that destroyed the fabric of our community, and called for armed demonstrations and chaos,” said its de facto spokesperson, Jamal Zubia. “We don’t care if people don’t support us. We know some people even still support Qaddafi and that’s their right, but they should not try to destabilize the government and create trouble.”

Despite such assurances and the quiet in the capital, Tripoli residents are slow to forget the heavy fighting from the summer. They are also acutely aware of clashes tearing apart towns and cities across Libya. Many worry it is only a matter of time before trouble returns. Such uncertainty has led to self-censorship, explaining why some Tripoli residents have turned to graffiti as a way to express subversive opinions. Under cover of darkness, they can anonymously pledge allegiance to the powers in the east with such phrases as: “Yes to Karama.” Even if these slogans are crossed out and replaced with a show of support for the Tripoli-based government, the original marks almost always remain legible, building a network of words and phrases reminding passersby that the capital is politically divided.

Tripoli’s graffiti also reflects some of the religious ideologies that have thrived in Libya since the ouster of Qaddafi’s, who had formerly kept a tight check on extremist views. Some graffiti equate Fajr Libya with Daash—the Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham—to which some members of Islamist militias in the eastern town of Derna have publicly pledged allegiance. Fajr Libya, however, says it is a political movement committed to a stable and secure Libya, and rejects terms such as “Islamist” that have sometimes been applied to it. Although Libyan society is deeply conservative and Islamic, extremist ideologies are often mistrusted—especially by those with connections to Benghazi, which has experienced the realities of life under locally imposed Islamist-affiliated militias. 

“I still support Operation Karama, although fighting has damaged the city,” said Salah, a local resident whose family remains in Benghazi while he works in Tripoli. “I’m prepared to have nothing—no electricity, gas, or petrol—as long as I never again see those people in balaclavas on the streets of my city.” Such thoughts are echoed in another inscription, which declares: “No to Ansar al-Sharia. Yes to the army and police.” This last phrase depicts the reality for many Libyans. Once full of post-revolutionary fervor and high hopes for the future of the country, their aspirations have been squashed. Exhausted by nearly four years of chaos, fighting, and instability, now most say all they wish for is a return to safety and stability.

Tom Westcott is a British journalist and writer based in Libya.

^{1. Interview with the author. ↩}