conference

2023 Global Technology Summit

December 4, 2023
New Delhi

The eighth Global Technology Summit, co-hosted with the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, themed Geopolitics of Technology, took place in New Delhi from December 4 to 6, 2023.

We convened industry experts, policymakers, and scholars from around the world to discuss digital public infrastructure (DPI), artificial intelligence (AI), critical and emerging technology, export controls, space, semiconductors, and more.

December 4: Introducing DPIs and AI.

December 5: DPI frameworks, design choices, adoption strategies, data protection, and national security and technology.

December 6: AI regulation, compute power, military applications, skilling and innovation, and critical and emerging technology.

  • December 4, 2023
  • December 5, 2023
  • December 6, 2023
December 4, 2023
Inaugural Address
Speaker
 

S. Jaishankar

External Affairs Minister of India
Inaugural Conversation: The Geo-Digital Age
Speaker
 

S. Jaishankar

External Affairs Minister of India
Moderator
 

Rudra Chaudhuri

Director
Carnegie India
Conversation: National Security and Technology
Speaker
 

Jonathan Finer

Principal Deputy National Security Advisor
United States of America
Moderator
 

Arun K. Singh

Nonresident Senior Fellow
Carnegie India
Keynote Address: Digital Public Intelligence: What Comes Next for DPIs and AI in India?
Speaker
 

Nandan Nilekani

Chairman and Co-Founder
Infosys and Founding Chairman
UIDAI (Aadhaar)
Ministerial Address
Speaker
 

Salima Bah

Minister of Communication, Technology and Innovation
Government of Sierra Leone
Panel: What Is the Future of Artificial Intelligence?

The transition of artificial intelligence (AI) to more advanced generative AI models is accelerating its transformative potential. However, there are questions about how different regulatory mechanisms will respond to the growing adoption of such AI systems. This panel explores the possibility of a global convergence on AI. Can governments, the private sector and civil society come together to steer the development of generative AI in a responsible manner, without blunting its transformative power?

Speakers
 

Abhishek Singh

Additional Secretary and Chief Executive Officer (NeGD)
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Government of India
 

Seth Center

Acting Special Envoy for Critical and Emerging Technology
Office of the Special Envoy for Critical and Emerging Technology
U.S. Department of State
 

Stefan Schnorr

State Secretary
Federal Ministry for Digital and Transport
Government of Germany
 

Emran Mian

Director General for Digital Technologies and Telecoms
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Government of the United Kingdom
 

Eunice Huang

Head of AI and Emerging Tech Policy
APAC
Google
 

Eric Loeb

Executive Vice President, Global Government Affairs
Salesforce
 

Ashutosh Chadha

Director and Country Head
Corporate Affairs and Public Policy, India and South Asia
Microsoft
Moderator
 

Mariano-Florentino (Tino) Cuéllar

President
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
December 5, 2023
Video Message
Speaker
 

Rajnath Singh

Defence Minister of India
Book Discussion: The Third Way: India’s Revolutionary Approach to Data Governance

The Third Way reviews India’s digital public infrastructure (DPI) from a governance lens. It also showcases how DPI helped India leapfrog decades in development. By introducing the “DPI approach” to governance, the author proposes a new way to embed regulatory principles directly into the code of the digital ecosystems they govern, so that private entities can freely innovate without worrying about overstepping the regulatory boundaries.

Speakers
 

Rahul Matthan

Partner
Trilegal
 

Nandan Nilekani

Chairman and Co-Founder
Infosys;
Founding Chairman
UIDAI (Aadhaar)
 

Mariano-Florentino (Tino) Cuéllar

President
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Moderator
 

Jane Munga

Fellow, Africa Program
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Panel: Globalizing DPI

The G20 Presidency of India has globalized the “DPI” terminology. More importantly, it introduced a unified framework that can help countries adopt the DPI approach to solve their problems through digital transformation, without having to reinvent the wheel. The panel discusses the strategies for overcoming DPI challenges and discovering collaborative opportunities to accelerate the globalization of DPI.

Speakers
 

Amitabh Kant

G20 Sherpa
Government of India
 

Salima Bah

Minister of Communication, Technology and Innovation
Government of Sierra Leone
 

Stefan Schnorr

State Secretary, Federal Ministry for Digital and Transport
Government of Germany
 

Dilip Asbe

Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer
National Payments Corporation of India (virtual)
 

Shivnath Thukral

Director and Head, Public Policy, India
Meta
Moderator
 

Kathleen McGowan

Senior Director for Policy
Digital Impact Alliance
Video Message
Speaker
 

Roberto de Oliveira Campos Neto

Governor of the Central Bank of Brazil
Conversation: AI and the New Frontiers of Biotechnology

The field of AI has made rapid strides in the last few years. Biotechnology, too, remains as dynamic as ever, with rapid developments in this field to have both societal impact as well as commercial success. However, the framework of regulation adopted in both AI and biotechnology will be critical in determining whether the need for regulation will come at the cost of innovation, or whether it may perhaps even accelerate it. What should be the new normal going ahead?

Speaker
 

Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw

Executive Chairperson
Biocon Limited and Biocon Biologics Limited
Moderator
 

George Perkovich

Ken Olivier and Angela Nomellini Chair and Vice President for Studies
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Keynote Address: India’s Digital Age
Speaker
 

S. Krishnan

Secretary, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Government of India
Talk: DPI Design and Deployment Choices
Speaker
 

Pramod Varma

Former Chief Architect, Aadhaar
India Stack;
Co-Chair
Centre for DPI
Panel: DPI Adoption: Technology, Governance, and Society

The panel discusses the challenges and opportunities of different deployment and adoption strategies for DPI – with perspectives from India, Singapore, World Bank, and the private sector. While DPIs have been successfully deployed and implemented at scale, several challenges persist.

Speakers
 

Pramod Varma

Former Chief Architect, Aadhaar
India Stack;
Co-Chair
Centre for DPI
 

Sopnendu Mohanty

Chief Fintech Officer
Monetary Authority of Singapore
 

Rohini Srivathsa

Chief Technology Officer
Microsoft India & South Asia
 

Jonathan Marskell

Senior Digital Development Specialist
The World Bank
 

Shalini Kapoor

Head, Public Sector and Chief Technologist
Amazon Web Services India
 

Vivek Sonny Abraham

Senior Director, External Strategy – India and South Asia
Salesforce
Moderator
 

Rudra Chaudhuri

Director
Carnegie India
Lightning Talk: Geopolitics and Critical Minerals and Materials

Critical materials and minerals assume significance in tech supply chains, and thus play a key part in geopolitics. How can developing nations, including India, forge partnerships and international alliances by leveraging innovative production of critical materials and minerals?

Speaker
 

Rajat Verma

Founder and Chief Executive Officer
Lohum Cleantech
Panel: Global Agenda for DPI

India’s presidency of the G20 has many lessons to offer, especially on the future of DPIs. There is now a need to detail the way forward for the global institutionalization of DPIs. The panel focuses on potential collaborations between various stakeholders and discusses broader issues regarding the governance and sustainability of DPIs.

Speakers
 

Sushil Pal

Joint Secretary, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Government of India
 

David Roos

Acting Head of Sector Project, International Digital Policy for Sustainable Development
GIZ (virtual)
 

Dushni Weerakoon

Executive Director
Institute of Policy Studies of Sri Lanka
 

Sabeen V. Dhanani

Deputy Director, Technology Division
United States Agency for International Development (USAID)
 

Kevin O’Neil

Managing Director, Data and Technology
Rockefeller Foundation
 

Keyzom Massally

Head of Digital Programmes
UNDP;
Board Member
Digital Public Goods Alliance
Moderator
 

Suhel Bidani

Lead, Digital
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (India Office)
Talk: Business Case for DPI
Speaker
 

T Koshy

Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer
Open Network for Digital Commerce
Panel: Economic Case for DPI

Private sector participation in the DPI ecosystem is key to unlocking innovation. Offerings by the private sector can reach consumers much faster and more efficiently when combined with DPIs. Allocation of risk, alignment of incentives, and market discipline are key for this sector. This panel explores how small and large businesses can build on top of DPIs.

Speakers
 

Anish Kumar

Advisor, Development Partnership Administration, Ministry of External Affairs
Government of India
 

Peter Rabley

Co-Founder and Managing Partner
PLACE
 

Anand Raghuraman

Director, Global Public Policy
Mastercard
 

Harsh Chugh

Chief Operating Officer
Kyndryl
 

Sabine Mensah

Deputy Chief Executive Officer
AfricaNenda
 

Kanwaljit Singh

Senior Program Officer, Financial Services for the Poor
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
Moderator
 

Dan Baer

Senior Vice President for Policy Research & Director, Europe Program
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Video Message
Speaker
 

Chan Cheow Hoe

Government Chief Digital Technology Officer
Smart Nation Group, Singapore
Conversation: AI, Innovation, and Payments

AI systems have proven to be a game-changer for payment systems. It ranges from simplifying payment systems to harnessing and making sense of the vast amount of data generated, among other advances. However, there are also attendant concerns, such as false declines and cybersecurity risks.

Speaker
 

Nitendra Rajput

Senior Vice President & Head, AI Garage
Mastercard
Moderator
 

Ashok Malik

Partner and Chair (India)
The Asia Group
Ministerial Address
Speaker
 

Rajkumar Ranjan Singh

Minister of State for External Affairs and Education
Government of India
Lightning Talk: Innovation Beyond Boundaries: DPIs in Education and Lifelong Learning
Speaker
 

Shankar Maruwada

Co-Founder and Chief Executive Officer
EkStep Foundation
Keynote Address: Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 Learning
Speaker
 

Baijayant Panda

National Vice President
Bharatiya Janata Party;
In-Charge,
Assam & Delhi Bharatiya Janata Party Units
Panel: Data Protection in the Global South

In recent years, many developing countries, such as India, Brazil, and Kenya, have passed data protection and data governance laws. This panel seeks to understand the approaches of these jurisdictions and the corresponding implications for the digital economy, human rights, and digital sovereignty.

Speakers
 

Baijayant Panda

National Vice President
Bharatiya Janata Party;
In-Charge,
Assam & Delhi Bharatiya Janata Party Units
 

Immaculate Kassait

Data Commissioner, Office of the Data Protection Commissioner
Government of Kenya
 

Miriam Wimmer

Director, Brazilian National Data Protection Authority
ANPD (virtual)
 

Phillip Armstrong

Senior Director, Head of JAPAC Privacy
Salesforce
 

Sandeep Aurora

Director, Government Affairs & Public Policy
Microsoft
Moderator
 

Suyash Rai

Deputy Director & Fellow
Carnegie India
Panel: Community-Driven Policy: A Multi-Stakeholder Approach

Government programs and policies play a crucial role in delivering fundamental services and tackling systemic issues. Meanwhile, philanthropy offers the adaptability and ingenuity required to address intricate, individualized, and localized challenges.

Speakers
 

Raghuram S

Joint Secretary (Policy, Planning & Research), Ministry of External Affairs
Government of India
 

Kanwaljit Singh

Senior Program Officer, Financial Services for the Poor
Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation
 

Nivedita Mehra

Managing Director
US-India Strategic Partnership Forum (India)
 

Carsten Maple

Turing Fellow,
The Alan Turing Institute
Moderator
 

Michael R. Nelson

Senior Fellow, Technology and International Affairs Program
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Conversation: Geopolitics of Technology
Speaker
 

Seth Center

Acting Special Envoy for Critical and Emerging Technology, Office of the Special Envoy for Critical and Emerging Technology
U.S. Department of State
Moderator
 

Arun K. Singh

Nonresident Senior Fellow
Carnegie India
Panel: Fragmentation: The Future of Geopolitics?

Recent geopolitical events, like the war in Ukraine and the crisis in the Middle East, have reshaped the international stage. It has become increasingly essential to examine the state of global relations and the role that technology plays in an interconnected yet fragmented world. Given the current state of affairs, this panel delves into the future interplay between geopolitics and technology.

Speakers
 

Vijay Chauthaiwale

In-Charge, Foreign Affairs Department
Bharatiya Janata Party
 

Philip Green

Australia’s High Commissioner to India
 

Dan Baer

Senior Vice President for Policy Research & Director, Europe Program
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
 

C. Raja Mohan

Senior Fellow
Asia Society Policy Institute
 

James Crabtree

Distinguished Visiting Fellow
European Council on Foreign Relations
 

Johanna Weaver

Founding Director, Tech Policy Design Centre
Australian National University
Moderator
 

Ashley J. Tellis

Tata Chair for Strategic Affairs and Senior Fellow
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
December 6, 2023
Ministerial Conversation
Speaker
 

Rajeev Chandrasekhar

Minister of State for Electronics and Information Technology and Minister of State for Skill Development and Entrepreneurship
Government of India
Moderator
 

Evan Feigenbaum

Vice President for Studies
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Video Message
Speaker
 

Eva Maydell

Member
European Parliament
Panel: Intelligent Regulation of AI: The Way Ahead

The global discourse on AI has transformed over the last year, and there is increased talk about the need to regulate this technology. However, approaches to regulating developments in generative AI will differ from government-to-government. This panel unpacks the implications of these differing approaches for the AI ecosystem.

Speakers
 

Rahul Matthan

Partner
Trilegal
 

Michael Sellitto

Head of Global Affairs, Anthropic, and Adjunct Senior Fellow
Center for a New American Security
 

Melinda Claybaugh

Director of Privacy and Data Policy
Meta
 

Marcus Bartley Johns

Senior Director, Asia, Government and Regulatory Affairs
Microsoft
 

Johanna Weaver

Founding Director, Tech Policy Design Centre
Australian National University
 

Raluca Csernatoni

Fellow
Carnegie Europe (virtual)
Moderator
 

Amlan Mohanty

Nonresident Scholar
Carnegie India
Keynote Address: GenAI: Early Learnings
Speaker
 

Mayur Datar

Senior Vice President and Chief Data Scientist
Flipkart
Conversation: Responsible AI: Building Bridges for the Future

The massive surge of interest in AI is perhaps exceeded only by the global efforts underway to ensure that AI systems adhere to the principles of responsible AI. Here, both companies, organizations, and civil society are in agreement on the need to establish certain guardrails.

Speaker
 

Evelyn Miller

Vice President, Privacy Policy
Meta
Moderator
 

Rahul Matthan

Partner
Trilegal
Keynote Address: Export Controls
Speaker
 

Thea D. Rozman Kendler

Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Export Administration, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS)
U.S. Department of Commerce
Panel: A Fork in the Road: The New Approach to Export Controls

In recent years, the export control policies of advanced industrial economies have increasingly been used to regulate global commerce in high-technology products. A notable example is the restrictions imposed on the sale of high-technology products like AI chips to China. This panel unpacks the consequences of such export curbs for the current geopolitical scenario.

Speakers
 

Vani Rao

Additional Secretary, Americas Division, Ministry of External Affairs
Government of India
 

Thea D. Rozman Kendler

Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Export Administration, Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS)
U.S. Department of Commerce
 

Peter Sandler

Director, Directorate General for Trade
European Commission (virtual)
 

Ansgar Baums

Helmut Schmidt Fellow
German Marshall Fund of the United States
Moderator
 

Sameer P. Lalwani

Senior Expert, South Asia Programs
U.S. Institute of Peace;
Nonresident Senior Fellow
Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments
Ministerial Address
Speaker
 

Meenakashi Lekhi

Minister of State for External Affairs and Culture
Government of India
Keynote Address: Driving Global AI Regulatory Framework
Speaker
 

Nivruti Rai

Managing Director & Chief Executive Officer
Invest India
Video Message
Speaker
 

Bill Nelson

NASA Administrator
Panel: iCET: The Way Forward

Officially launched in January 2023, the Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology (iCET) elevated India-U.S. ties and modernized them. It has promoted more frequent government-to- government interactions and prioritized engagement among a broader coalition of non-governmental stakeholders. This panel charts the roadmap for the future of iCET.

Speakers
 

Tarun Chhabra

Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for Technology and National Security
National Security Council, The White House
 

Vivek Lall

Chief Executive
General Atomics Global Corporation
 

Nivruti Rai

Managing Director & Chief Executive Officer
Invest India
 

Chantal Lakatos de Alcantara

Managing Director, Global Government Affairs
Lam Research
 

Arun K. Singh

Nonresident Senior Fellow
Carnegie India
Moderator
 

Nitin Gokhale

Founder and Chief Executive Officer
BharatShakti.in
Keynote Address: Military Applications of AI

Discussions regarding the harms of AI have largely focused on misinformation and labor force displacement. However, the Global North appears to be increasingly concerned about the national security risks posed by military applications of generative AI. This panel outlines these risks and discusses the scope of regulating them.

Speaker
 

Izumi Nakamitsu

Under-Secretary-General and High Representative for Disarmament Affairs
United Nations
Panel: Military Applications of AI
Speakers
 

Izumi Nakamitsu

Under-Secretary-General and High Representative for Disarmament Affairs
United Nations
 

Anupam Ray

Ambassador and Permanent Representative of India to the Conference on Disarmament
 

Eric Desautels

Senior Coordinator for Emerging Technologies and Security Domains, Bureau of Arms Control, Deterrence, and Stability
U.S. Department of State
 

Raj Shukla

Member
Union Public Service Commission
 

John Tasioulas

Professor of Ethics and Legal Philosophy; Director of the Institute for Ethics in AI
University of Oxford
 

Isaac Ben-Israel

Professor Emeritus
Tel-Aviv University (virtual)
Moderator
 

Konark Bhandari

Fellow
Carnegie India
Talk: Compute Power for AI
Speaker
 

Arun K. Subramaniyan

Vice President, Cloud & AI Strategy
Intel Corporation
Video Message
Speaker
 

Karolis Žemaitis

Vice Minister of Economy and Innovation
Government of Lithuania
Lightning Talk: An AI Strategy for an Adbhut India: Leveraging India’s Strengths
Speaker
 

Tanuj Bhojwani

Head
People+ai
Panel: The Evolving AI Landscape: Risks and Responsibilities

Conversations around the state of AI involve several “either/or” exaggerations—potential applications are discussed without a fair analysis of the possibilities and limitations, and risk assessments are either downplayed or overblown. This panel addresses the need of the h our: a clear understanding of the evolving state of AI and its foreseeable future.

Speakers
 

Sunil Abraham

Public Policy Director, Data Economy and Emerging Tech
Meta India
 

Eunice Huang

Head of AI and Emerging Tech Policy, APAC
Google
 

Mathis Börner

Senior AI Scientist, AI CTO Office
SAP (virtual)
 

Balaraman Ravindran

Head, Robert Bosch Centre for Data Science & Artificial Intelligence & Centre for Responsible AI
IIT Madras
 

Lea Gimpel

Senior Policy Manager, Countries, Resource Mobilization & AI
Digital Public Goods Alliance
 

Audrey Plonk

Head of Digital Economy Division, Directorate of Science, Technology and Innovation
OECD (virtual)
Moderator
 

Aubra Anthony

Senior Fellow, Technology and International Affairs Program
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Keynote Address: AI, Skilling, and Innovation
Speaker
 

Sarah Kemp

Vice President, International Government Affairs
Intel Corporation
Video Message
Speaker
 

Christian Klein

Chief Executive Officer and Executive Board Member
SAP SE
Panel: AI: Skilling and Innovation

An important dimension of the socioeconomic debate on AI is the scarcity of talent in the field. Given the radical transformations likely to occur in the labor market, the role of policymakers in preparing the workforce for the AI revolution cannot be understated. Accordingly, this panel discusses the AI skilling frameworks of various countries.

Speakers
 

Mahaveer Singhvi

Joint Secretary (New Emerging and Strategic Technologies Division), Ministry of External Affairs
Government of India
 

Lovneesh Chanana

Senior Vice President and Regional Head for Government Affairs, Asia Pacific and Japan
SAP
 

Kirti Seth

Chief Executive Officer, IT-ITES Sector Skills Council
NASSCOM
 

Aditi Jha

Director and Country Head, Legal and Government Affairs
LinkedIn India
 

Vukosi Marivate

Associate Professor of Computer Science and ABSA UP Chair of Data Science
University of Pretoria (virtual)
Moderator
 

Ian Klaus

Founding Director
Carnegie California
Video Message
Speaker
 

Lucilla Sioli

Director, Artificial Intelligence and Digital Industry
European Commission
Conversation: Ambassadors’ Journal
Speakers
 

Harsh Vardhan Shringla

Chief Coordinator
India’s G20 Presidency
 

Eric Garcetti

Ambassador of the United States of America to India
Moderator
 

Rudra Chaudhuri

Director
Carnegie India
Panel: Geopolitics Today: Shifting Sands or Structural Transformation?

Thirty years ago, the Cold War ended, leading to an era of “unipolarity,” which morphed into various versions of bipolarity and arguably, multipolarity too. Today, we possibly stand at the crossroads of a new era. This panel discusses the current age of uncertainty and whether it marks a more pronounced shift toward a new world order.

Speakers
 

Alex Ellis

British High Commissioner to India
 

Diana Mickevičienė

Ambassador of Lithuania to India
 

Ashley J. Tellis

Tata Chair for Strategic Affairs and Senior Fellow
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
 

Evan Feigenbaum

Vice President for Studies
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
 

D B Venkatesh Varma

Distinguished Fellow
Vivekananda International Foundation
Moderator
 

Molly Gambhir

Senior News Anchor
WION
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.