Few figures have inspired as much admiration—and as much argument—as Mahatma Gandhi. His ideas helped shape struggles for freedom and equality around the world. Yet his views on caste, race, gender, and modern life continue to provoke debate.
What can we learn from those arguments? And how should we judge a thinker whose capacity to challenge injustice sometimes coexisted with prejudices of his own?
Milan’s guest on the show this week is the historian and Gandhi biographer Ramachandra Guha. His new book, Arguments with Gandhi, examines Gandhi’s ideas through four themes—violence, justice, faith, and progress—and asks what they can teach us about the world we inhabit today.
Ram Guha is is the author of the landmark history, India After Gandhi, which remains an indispensable guide to understanding post-1947 India. He is also the author of a two-volume biography on Gandhi, each of which was chosen by the New York Times as a Notable Book of the Year. Ram is a Distinguished University Professor at Krea University and a return guest to Grand Tamasha.
Milan and Ram discuss the inspiration for his new book, Gandhi’s unique geographic and thematic range, and the origins of his ideas on civil disobedience. Plus, the two discuss Ram’s continuing personal journey with Gandhi—and what comes next.
Episode notes:
1. “Ramachandra Guha Revisits India After Gandhi,” Grand Tamasha, April 19, 2023.
2. Sudarshan Kapur, Raising Up A Prophet: The African-American Encounter With Gandhi (Boston: Beacon Press, 1992).
Transcript
Note: this is an AI-generated transcript and may contain errors
Milan Vaishnav Welcome to Grand Tamasha, a co-production of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and the Hindustan Times. I'm your host, Milan Vaishnav. Few figures have inspired as much admiration and as much argument as Mahatma Gandhi. His ideas helped shape struggles for freedom and equality around the world, yet his views on caste, race, gender, and modern life continue to provoke debate. What can we learn from those arguments, and how should we judge a thinker whose capacity to challenge injustice sometimes coexisted with prejudices of his own? My guest this week is the historian and Gandhi biographer, Ramachandra Guha. His new book, Arguments with Gandhi, examines Gandhi's ideas through four themes: violence, justice, faith, and progress, and ask what they can teach us about the world we inhabit today. Ram Guha is of course, the author of the landmark history, India After Gandhi, which remains, in my mind, the best guide to understanding post-1947 India. He's also the author of a two-volume biography on Gandhi, each of which was chosen by the New York Times as a notable book of the year. He's a distinguished university professor at CREA University and a return guest to Grand Tamasha. I'm pleased to welcome him back to the show. Ram, congrats on the book. And I just want to mention to our listeners that it is now available in India as well as in the United States and elsewhere. Thanks very much for taking the time.
Ramachandra Guha Thank you, Milan.
Milan Vaishnav So I want to start by asking you to tell us a little bit about the inspiration for this book. You have spent a lifetime, virtually, thinking about Gandhi and Gandhi's legacy. But as you mentioned in the opening pages, there was an August 2019 incident that took place at your alma mater, Adelaide University, that really, for you, sealed the deal that this book needed to be written and it needed to be written at this point in time. Tell us a little bit about what that incident was and why it convinced you to go forward with this project?
Ramachandra Guha So Milan, long before this incident which happened in 2019, I taught a course at the University of California at Berkeley with the title, Arguments with Gandhi. So, I was thinking around these lines and then I wrote my biography, which is really less about ideas and arguments and more about life, struggles, relationships, friendships, rivalries, loves. It's a personal and political biography of Gandhi. It is not a book about his philosophy and his broader outlook on life. So, I published that and I set aside the original idea and that this statue appeared on my horizon. And I said, look, these debates that Gandhi had in his lifetime are still so active today. And that statue was just to alert or acquaint your listeners. That statue was of three Indian nationalists. One was a right-wing Hindu fundamentalist, Savarkar. A second was a left-wing Maoist revolutionary, Bhagat Singh. And the third was a militant freedom fighter who allied with Hitler and the Axis powers, Subhash Bose. Now, the statue was erected by the student wing of the RSS, the Hindu supremacist organization. So Savarkar was a natural fit, but Bhagat Singh was an atheist. So how the hell was he there? And Bose actually deeply believed in Hindu-Muslim harmony. For all his admiration for European strong men, he deeply believed into Hindu-Muslim harmony. So, he also didn't fit in an ideological sense. I think it struck me that the ABVP and the RSS and the Hindu right generally so vilifies Gandhi that these three men were brought together by the simple fact that that at some stage in their career, they had argued with Gandhi. So here, Gandhi was the absent figure in the statue. You know, he was the absent enemy, almost the rakshasa, or the evil person, these three were combating or trying to defeat. So, and I thought, look, here, I must look at Gandhi's arguments in his lifetime and afterwards, you know. Clearly, he had debates with the friends, rivals, colleagues, adversaries, some of which I described in this book. But there's such an enduring afterlife. And then the title of the book also captures the double-sidedness of these arguments. So, arguments with Gandhi, against Gandhi, refuting and disputing and repudiating his views. And arguments with Gandhi, taking his ideas and techniques forward, as for example Martin Luther King, on whom I devote a whole chapter. So that's how this book came about.
Milan Vaishnav You know, you write that another reason to pursue a book project like this is because Gandhi stands out in two significant respects, right? On the one hand, there's the geographic range of his experience, of course his time spent in South Africa, his time studying abroad, his time in India, of course. But also not just his geographic range, but the thematic range of his public activities. And I wonder if you could just elaborate a bit on these unique dimensions of Gandhi's legacy.
Ramachandra Guha First of all, Gandhi lived a long life, he lived almost 80 years, and he lived several years in England, which is in the continent of Europe, even though the British don't always want to acknowledge that. He lived 20 years in South Africa, which was at the tip of the South African continent, and 20 years, in India which is part of Asia. So, a person who lived his life across three continents, and in India he had traveled to virtually every district of this vast and diverse land. So that's the geographical range, which is not unique, but rare among political leaders whose activities are usually confined to their own country. For example, Milan, the great Chinese communist leader Mao really never left his homeland. Stalin was always in the broader Russian territory. And the only time he left was when he was head of government and he had to go [elsewhere] for an international conference. So here is a man who has lived his life across three continents. Here is the man who's had, as I argue, multiple professions. He was a politician fighting for freedom from the British. He was also a social reformer trying to address, with mixed success, inequalities within his own society. He was the religious thinker trying to build bridges between Hindus and Muslims who are often rivalrous and at each other's throats. He was also an experimenter in alternate lifestyles. You know, he's a pioneer, you could say, of the counter-cultural movement. That's four careers. And this actually, before all of this, he had been a lawyer for more than a decade, you know. So, there was a fifth career, he started it, and possibly even a sixth as a writer. You know, both you and I write books, but you know, Gandhi's output, you know, dwarfed us multiple times. I mean, he was an editor of a newspaper, he was a journalist, he was an autobiographer, he was a political commentator. So, I thought that also makes him absolutely unique among political figures, the range of his life and the range his activity.
Milan Vaishnav The book, as I mentioned at the beginning, is structured around four themes that exercise Gandhi. They continue to be, in many ways, kind of central preoccupations of our world. If you think about, you know, violence, justice, faith, progress, we'll touch on each of these in due course, but I wonder if you could just reflect a bit on the selection of these themes. I mean, as I was reading the book, I had this question, you know, did they sort of emerge organically as, okay, these are the obvious four choices, or was it hard to whittle down the list to just these ideas?
Ramachandra Guha Well, I think these are the obvious four choices in the light of what I've just told you, Milan, about his multiple careers. Nonviolence, because that was his preferred political technique that captured Gandhi, the politician. Justice across three realms, caste, gender and race, because that talked about Gandhi as a social reformer. Faith, because that captures Gandhi's ceaseless attempt to understanding religions other than his own. And finally, progress, because it was rather heterodox views about industrialization and modern economics. There could have been a fifth theme, which is language and culture. You know, there's an early footnote to the book where I say that, you know, among the people Gandhi had the most interesting arguments with were his friend and contemporary, the great Bengali poet Rabindranath Tagore. But those were really about language and culture and xenophobia. And though fascinating in themselves, those debates did not figure in this book. But I put that footnote right on page six or eight of the book, Milan, because I knew there would be objections, particularly from our Bengali comrades who are, you know, so vociferous in Indian intellectual life, and they are coming, I mean, I got a letter three days ago from a professor in Calcutta saying, I liked your book, and why is there no Tagore? I said, didn't you see the footnote, right on this? Please see it. But so, clearly, it is not comprehensive. There are also the debates that Gandhi had on themes such as diet and natural food and health. So, these four central themes are representative, but not exhaustive.
Milan Vaishnav I want to maybe start with the first one you address in the book, which is the question of non-violence. And that section begins with an event that took place on September 11th, but not the September 11th that most of our listeners will think about, which of course is September 11, 2001. This refers to September 11, 1906 and protests in Johannesburg that were organized to oppose proposed discriminatory legislation in the Transvaal, which is a province of South Africa. Tell us a little bit about what happened that day and why it was or came to be a sort of turning point in Gandhi's approach to resistance.
Ramachandra Guha So again, to rehearse some basic biographical markers, Gandhi is born in 1889 in Kathiawar in Western India. He goes to study the law in England, returns to India, fails to establish himself in his homeland, and then moves to South Africa, and practices as a lawyer there for almost a decade before becoming a community activist. You know, South Africa was a society ruled by the Europeans, with Africans and Indians as subordinate subject people. And Gandhi was not representing the Africans. In fact, he was, at one state, hostile to Africans, which we will talk about. He was really a leader of the Indian community alone, who numbered roughly 150,000 members of the diaspora. And they were petitioning for greater rights, you know, their restrictions on where they live, where they could feed, how many Indians could live and come in, whether they could practice their customary religion. And Gandhi became the representative of the community, pleading for greater rights from the white rulers. And this pleading took the form of petitions, polite documents addressed in the earnest King's English, beseeching the rulers to honor the British sense of justice and their Christian faith. And grant their Indian and non-Christian subjects, you know, some greater leeway in how they live their lives. And it was after years of petitioning failed, a decade of petition failed, Gandhi decided to go to England because South Africa was still ruled by the imperial government in England, and for a last-ditch effort to persuade the rulers. And before going to England, a bit before going England, a meeting of the Indians was convened in Johannesburg, in a hall called the Empire Theater, which no longer exists. It was burnt down. And this meeting was convened on the 11th of September 1906, 95 years before the better known and more infamous 9-11. And at that meeting there was a kind of, you know, the Indians resolve to do certain things. And they also address the British, and they criticize the laws, the racist laws as being un-British, and theoretical but un-British, contrary to the British sense of justice. And they said, we urge you to rescind these laws, and if you will not, we will resist and go to jail. And then Gandhi goes to London shortly afterwards, because he wants to give the rulers a last chance. And while he's there, first of all, he makes an absolute…has a cold reception from the imperial authorities, who refused to entertain his pleas. It was incidentally on that 1906 meeting, on the 1906 trip to London, that Gandhi meets for the first and only time Winston Churchill, who was undersecretary of state for the colonies, and later, of course, was to call Gandhi all kinds of names. And so, but while the white, the ministers of the imperial government in London are so indifferent, you know, Gandhi while he's going to meet ministers and lobby with MPs and going to the House of Parliament in Westminster, he sees women protesters on the street asking for the vote. You know, at this stage only men could vote in British elections. And the women suffragettes, as they were known, were protesting on the street, bravely, courageously, but nonviolently. And Gandhi was so impressed. And his, you know, his colleagues had just taken a vow that they would protest if Gandhi's mission was unsuccessful. And here he sees examples of absolutely determined, resolute women asking for the vote. And he says, we must follow the example of these women, which is what they do when Gandhi goes back.
Milan Vaishnav I mean, it's a kind of remarkable sequence of events. But I, you know, I think the chronology here is very interesting, and it becomes a central theme of this chapter, because I think many of us were taught that Gandhi derived a lot of his ideas on civil disobedience from the great thinker Henry David Thoreau. But you actually argue in this book that the chronology does not support that account. Where does Thoreau fit into Gandhi’s ideas of nonviolent civil resistance?
Ramachandra Guha When Gandhi and his colleagues decide to court arrest through collective disobedience, in 1906-1907, Gandhi had not read Thoreau. The examples he invokes are the British suffragettes whom I have mentioned and Indian peasants back in his homeland who went on dharma, which is kind of a street demonstration against an unjust ruler who had levied excessively high taxes. It's after he, his first protest that our English friend gives him Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience to read and through Thoreau, Gandhi finds, retrospective justification for his actions, not prior inspiration, but retrospective justifications.
Milan Vaishnav I mean, that's very, very, very interesting and it also puts the suffragettes, I think more front and center of this conversation than perhaps they've been before. Of course, after Gandhi launches this program of Satyagraha, he would go on to inspire many people, not least Martin Luther King Jr., who once when talking about his project of civil disobedience in America said, quote, Christ furnished the spirit and motivation while Gandhi furnished The Method, which is a lovely saying.
Ramachandra Guha Lovely line, yeah.
Milan Vaishnav Tell us a little bit about how King first encounters Gandhi's ideas and how did he come to adapt them for the particular struggle of civil rights in America.
Ramachandra Guha So on the question of “how does King encounter Gandhi's ideas,” there's King's version based on what he said and there's the version which is slightly different based on my book. So, King says that when he was a student at Crozier Theological Seminary in Philadelphia in the year 1950, he heard a lecture by a visiting theologian called Monica Johnson, which talked about Gandhi. Johnson had just come back from India, and King says he was so inspired that he went to the bookshop and bought whatever books were available on Gandhi, which are probably Gandhi's autobiography and Louis Fisher's Life of Mahatma Gandhi, which had just been published. Now that is entirely plausible that's how King first heard of Gandhi. But the occasion when Gandhi's method proved useful to King occurs six years later in Montgomery, when Gandhi, again, Justice Thoreau does not initiate Gandhi's protests in South Africa. Gandhi does not initiate King's protests in Montgomery, Alabama. It's a same stretch called Rosa Parks who refused to get up from his seat that she was sitting on and it's an act of satyagraha or individual civil disobedience. And that, you know, King happens to be a pastor in that city and then of course a boycott is organized, a collective strike and in the early days of that strike, two admirers of Gandhi a black called Bayard Rustin and a white called Glenn Smiley are sent by the Fellowship of Reconciliation to work with King. And they tell King more about Gandhi and then he starts reading more and encounters several Americans who had visited Gandhi in the thirties and forties and lived with Gandhi, and it inspired by him. And that's how then King, you know, said. So, it's an interesting parallel. I mean, King is fundamental to Gandhi. As he reads Gandhi closely, he expands his ideas, there's some very striking parallels between their lives, including how they organize, how they build a cadre of devoted workers, how they pursue interfaith harmony, how they're committed to non-violence, how they both go to jail, and how they write seminal texts in jail, you know, of the non-violent. All of that is true, but in a sense, it's serendipity. It's Rosa Parks who sparks, who was doing what she did, independent of King or Gandhi or anyone else. But King, that becomes so interested in Gandhi that he comes to India, and he travels around the country, and he meets Gandhi's direct disciples and I write about that too. So, but one last thing about King and Gandhi. I start that chapter with an account of how, before King was born, in the 19, as early as the 1920s, African-American periodicals were writing about Gandhi. You know, in 1920, 21, Gandhi launched his first major campaign against the British Raj. He was now back in India, and he launched a non-cooperation movement. And African-American periodical was saying, this technique of non-violence can be used by us to combat racial prejudice in our country. So, this is before King was born. So, the history of Gandhi in America is a very complex, interesting one which I have written about in this chapter. It's been written about other people. I'd like to especially acknowledge the pioneering work of the Indian American scholar Sudarshan Kapur, who wrote a remarkable book called Raising Up a Prophet, which tracks every report on Gandhi in the African-American press in the 1920s and 30s, before King was born and while King was a little boy, to show the prehistory of this black interest in Gandhi, the African-Americans in that.
Milan Vaishnav So I want to maybe pivot to asking you about something that was a bit more specific to the Indian scene. Although analogies of course, have been made across countries, which is this issue of caste. And when Gandhi first began speaking about caste, he was really focused on attacking the idea of untouchability rather than taking on the caste system wholesale. Of course, over time, this became a major bone of contention between Gandhi and another leading light of the period, B.R. Ambedkar, the father of the Constitution. Tell us a little bit about the source of the fundamental disagreement between these two men, and how far did Gandhi's position change in response to these conversations in this back and forth with Ambedkar.
Ramachandra Guha So the source of the disagreement was, first of all, different social locations. Gandhi was a guilt-ridden upper caste man. You know, Ambedkar was an untouchable who had experienced discrimination, deprivation himself. So, he felt it firsthand. So, in a sense, if you look at American analogy, Gandhi is to Ambedkar as Lincoln is to Frederick Douglass. All right. Now, Gandhi is, at the same time, there's another complication. Gandhi is trying to lead a broader struggle for freedom, and he wants to draw in as many sections of the population. And a large section of population is conservative, wants freedom from the British, but is not sure about discrimination within Hindu society. So, Gandhi judges it wise to move slowly. Now Ambedkar wants—he is a brilliant thinker, he has a PhD from Columbia and the NSCE, he is a man of great intelligence, energy, completely self-made and as I said, someone born at the bottom of the social hierarchy who has known what suffering and oppression are. And he is impatient. He's also much younger than Gandhi. So he says, he tells Gandhi you're going too slow, attack the class system frontally, just don't just say untouchability is bad, say the system must go, there must be full-fledged intermarriage, you know, the scriptures that mandate it are mistaken, this malicious practice are mistaken. So, it's a compelling argument, conducted over a decade and a half, which I try and document in that chapter, not as an ideologue, I hope, but as a scholar, trying to understand both people's points of view. And indeed, Gandhi does change in response to Ambedkar's brilliant and searing critiques of his original position. And that's … But it is, it is an epic debate. It has echoes even now. Now too, there are some people who pit Gandhi against Ambedkar. There are others who will try to bring them together. So, in the current context, they are, you know, they're complementary. Gandhi's part is the part of self-renewal. Ambedkar’s part is a part of self-respect because Gandhi is addressing himself to upper castes who are prejudiced. Ambedkar is addressing himself to lower castes who are discriminated against. Gandhi is telling the upper caste to rid themselves of the superiority complex. Ambedkar is telling Dalits or the untouchables to rid themselves of their inferiority complex. So, there are interesting and subtle ways in which you can see them today as complementary and that's what I argue, that's how my chapter ends. But I mean, this is one last thing I'd say. You know, yeah this is a debate that has fascinated me for 30 years and I've written about it in the past too. But given you know these two one old enough to be, Gandhi, old enough to be Ambedkar's father. Gandhi, the leader of the freedom struggle and the aura of a mahatma. Ambedkar seeking his place in the sun. Gandhi, a man of the spirit, Ambedkar, a rational intellectual. You know, it's a debate, an argument, which the historian can write about with only so much flair. It requires a novelist or better still a playwright, I think, to capture all its emotional intensity.
Milan Vaishnav Could I just ask you a quick follow-up on this? I mean, there was a pivotal moment that resulted in something known as the Poona Act, which was a resolution to this debate that the two men had over the question of should there be separate electorates for Dalits or should they be treated just like everybody else, but perhaps a system of affirmative action or reservation be put into place, which would guarantee them representation? And the latter, of course, is what ended up having, and that was many years later, codified into the Constitution. Were either of these men happy with that compromise?
Ramachandra Guha No, because Ambedkar was not, because Ambedkar felt that maybe if you have that in the system of joint electorates, the untouchable representatives will be beholden to the upper class. Gandhi was not, because Gandhi, both of them saw it as an inevitable compromise, but neither was entirely happy. Gandhi because Gandhi was really interested in transforming people's minds, not using the law as a brunt instrument of social change. As in people changing on the ground through their own collective action. But it was an inevitable compromise and that's why democracy is about: compromise. Democracy is not utopia. And that's how it ended up in the constitution. And though Ambedkar was deeply ambivalent about the Poona Act, when it came to the constitution who was drafting, he so adroitly oversaw, you know, he went along with the provisions of the Poona Act.
Milan Vaishnav I want to talk about gender because that in some ways was one of the most, for me anyway, eye-opening sections of the book. And if the way you tell the story is two years after Gandhi returns to India in 1915, he delivers this major political speech in which he links the struggle for Swaraj or self-rule to kind of two internal divides taking place in India. The first is this chasm or this gulf between the educated classes and the masses of the population. And then the second internal divide is the exclusion of women from public life. Now Gandhi, we know, had a very conservative upbringing in Gujarat. What led him to ultimately see women's participation as essential to the struggle for freedom? Was it that suffragette moment he had when he was visiting Britain or was there kind of a larger context to that?
Ramachandra Guha So, it was partly the suffragette moment he had an experience he had in Britain, but it was also the friendship of two European women in South Africa. So, before Gandhi returns to India in 1915, as we've discussed, he spends two decades in South Africa. And there he encounters two women. One, a British Christian called Millie Pollack, who is the wife of his best friend, and with whom the Gandhis and the Pollacks share a home in Johannesburg. And the other Sonja Schlesin, who is Jewish originally from Eastern Europe, who is Gandhi's secretary in her office. And Millie Polak and Sonja Schlesin are both independent-minded women with a sense of agency, not forced into submission in the way Indian women are. And they both argue with Gandhi about greater rights of women and why that's so important. And in South Africa itself, a few women joined the struggle, Indian women. So, but it's really the opening of Gandhi's mind, just as it's Ambedkar and perhaps one other reformer, Narayana Guru of Kerala, who opened Gandhi's mind to the question of caste. It is the suffragettes in England and then Millie Polak and Sonja Schlesin in South Africa who opened his mind with regard to gender. So, he comes back and he says women must join the freedom struggle. But as I document in that chapter, he is still ambivalent about what role they can play. They can be a supportive role. They can, for example, participate in promoting indigenous cloth, by cutting foreign goods. But they can't go to jail. Later on, it's another remarkable woman, an Indian this time, Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, who is the subject of a wonderful recent biography by the American scholar Nico Slate, who insists that women must go to jail too and become full equal partners in the struggle for freedom. And one of the most remarkable features of Gandhi's life, Milan, which distinguishes him not just from most other politicians, but from most other Indian males, dare I say most other males of any nationalities, is his ability to change and respond to criticism and grow. So, Ambedkar makes him change, the women's suffragettes make him change, Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay makes him change. But on two aspects, his views on gender remain deeply, deeply from what was deeply problematic then and remain deeply problematic now. The first was just opposition to contraception. So, Gandhi for had a peculiar obsession with celibacy. He saw sex, the sexual act as sinful, and he thought you must control your animal passions and only have sex—husband and wife must only have sex when they had wanted to have a child. That was problematic then. And the other was, of course, his adherence to the conventional conservative stereotype of man, of in a marriage, the man as a breadwinner and the woman as the homemaker. So full participation of women in the economy was something, maybe at that stage, the 1930s and 40s, that was the norm. I mean, most men believed that in America too. I mean, but at the same time, he did many things, he brought many women into the freedom struggle. He got a woman-elected president of the Indian National Congress in 1925. This was the poet Sarojini Naidu at a time when Republicans and Democrats in America hardly had any female representation at their higher levels. So, it's a very, very mixed bag, we may say, when it comes to gender.
Milan Vaishnav I mean, [its] the second kind of contradiction, if you want to call it, that I find really interesting, right? Because he was ambivalent about women participating in paid employment out of the house. When it came to politics and social mobilization, he seemed to understand that you couldn't leave 50% of the population behind. But when it came to the economic fate of the country, he didn't necessarily have the same view, right? I mean, he could not reconcile their political participation with his views about what their domestic role should be.
Ramachandra Guha Absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, but that was the conventional thinking at the time. I mean it takes American feminism, where women must play an equal role in the economy, in the professions, in the academy, in politics. It's really a post-Second World War phenomenon or a post 1970s phenomenon indeed. So, in this respect Gandhi was of his type. I find this, I don't excuse it, but I find it understandable. I find his opposition to contraception much more problematic because it puts all the burden on the women.
Milan Vaishnav All right I want to come back to something, Ram, you mentioned earlier when you were describing Gandhi's years in South Africa, which is this troubling question of race. In his early years in South Africa, as you document, he expressed racist views about Africans and he often used derogatory language in describing them. But over two decades, there was an evolution. And you say that by the end of his time South Africa, 1914-1915, he gradually became a non-racist. And I'm wondering if you could tell us a little bit about what drove that change and was it a complete change by the time he left for India?
Ramachandra Guha No, so it was a gradual change. It was because of his experience. I mean, he goes, Gandhi, remember Milan, is, what is it, 24 when he goes to South Africa. A young man, shaped by Indian culture, which is profoundly racist to this day. I mean Indians, as you know very well, are obsessed with skin color. And they were much more so then. And Gandhi grew up with the conventional views that being white skinned meant somehow being more civilized and more cultured and more lucky and more favored by God and more human. And he goes with those. He sees Africans, black Africans as backward, sometimes as savage and as ignorant, as lazy. I mean, he uses all those epithets in his early writings. Then he starts living, watching more closely. The longer he lives, he starts observing them and he sees them in different roles. He sees some extraordinary black reformers. There's a there's a black reformer called Jabavu who opens a series of schools and he says why can't look at him and now he's organizing Africans to go to school for Africans. Why can't we do that? Then he sees that the discrimination against Indians is also practiced against Africans. He sees the existence of segregated sporting grounds where blacks have to sit separately from whites to watch cricket. He sees African farmers working on the land, and he sees that not at all in the in the Inderland, they're as hardworking and as committed to, you know, their vocation as anyone else. So that is and then he meets people. Again, he meets a remarkable white woman, the pioneering feminist Olive Shiner, who is a committed anti-racist. So, Gandhi is moving, opening his mind. But in answer to your question, he does. He moves from being a racist to being a non-racist. It's only after he returns to India that he becomes a committed anti-racist. And in the 1920s and 30s, I've talked about his encounter with African Americans. Later on, in the late 30s and early 40s, when he's consulted by the Indians in South Africa on how to battle the continuing white discrimination against them, he says, look, in my time, it was Indians for themselves, Africans for themselves. Now it must be a unity of Asians and Africans. Unity of all the exploited races of the earth. So, it's a, you know, one has to, as always, there's a distinction between scholarship and ideological polemic. And a polemist or ideologue looks at 1926 from the perspective of 2026. A historian or scholar must put himself or herself in the minds and feet of the people living in 1926, or in Gandhi's case, 1876, sometimes, and see from that perspective how what he thinks, what he feels, and how he changes. And you can clearly see the evolution of Gandhi's views. Now, if you want to make a point, you will pick out Gandhi's early statement, say he's a racist, and not look at whatever he says about the subject of the next 40 years, which is what several scholars have done, so-called scholars, that's and I looked very systematically and closely at his entire body of writings and his entire body of acquaintances and experiences, and you can see a distinct evolution from racist to non-racist to anti-racism.
Milan Vaishnav There's another interesting thing that's going on also, which comes up in this chapter, right? Which is, ironically, it was Gandhi's experience in South Africa that exposes him to the diversity of India, right, which is a bit of a strange thing to say, given that Gandhi, of course, grew up in India. But you say it really wasn't until he became a lawyer in South Africa that he began to regularly mix with Indians of all different backgrounds, right? And so, in a sense, those relationships Gandhi had in South Africa changed his understanding of what it meant to be Indian.
Ramachandra Guha About so because you know I mean India today of course is very different from Gandhi's time. Now, there's a great deal of migration across different parts of India, but when Gandhi was growing up in the 1880s and 1890s and he was, you know, the people he spoke to spoke the same language with him was same religion often the same caste. In South Africa, he meets non Gujaratis non-Hindus, you know, and people from South India, East India, his first client in South Africa is a Muslim. When he starts a major struggle, his struggle, the first funder is a Parsi. Where he is brutally attacked and almost killed, the person who nurses him back to health is a Christian. When the struggle recommences and his fellow Gujaratis are too nervous to go to court and get arrested a second time, it's a Muslim called A.M. Kachalia who revives the struggle. Incidentally, A. M. Kachalia’s sons were later friends of Nelson Mandela and part of the anti-apartheid struggle in South Africa in the 40s and 50s. It's an interesting historical connection I've drawn in the book. So that's really what happens, and you know, and then of course he comes back to India, and then he starts traveling around India. You know, his mentor Gokhale tells him, when Gandhi returns in 1950, for a year, you must not utter a political comment. You must just get to know the country you don't know. And it goes to every nook and corner. I mean, you know, there's a wonderful book, you know in the bookshelf behind me, there's, I mean this bookshelf right behind me there is full of books by and about Gandhi. And one of them, this is a very rare and scarce book. It's called Gandhi, A Chronology, 1915 to 1948 by Chandu Bhai Dalal. And this is the Gujarati scholar who documented Gandhi's travels in India day by day by day by day and every place he went to and there is an index of places and you can see. I mean no Indian today has been to so many places as Gandhi, even though transportation is so much easier. You know, so, I think his South African experience exposed him to the diversity of India and convinced him that when he returned to his homeland, he must soak in this diversity, you know, really truly properly. You can understand it. If he sought to be the leader of a freedom struggle against British rule, presumably he meant to represent all of India, not just his caste, his gender, his religion, his region, his religion or whatever.
Milan Vaishnav So, Ram, there's one more kind of substantive point that I want to take up with you, which is, again, a major feature of the book, which is the subject of religion. And Gandhi's politics, as you have argued in this book and other books, was deeply rooted in religion, but he insisted that India belonged equally to people of every faith. And, you know, there's an older literature in which we used to talk about three schools of thought on the subject of religion and life in India. You had sort of Nehruvian secularism, you had Hindu nationalism, and then you had a third school of thought that people have called kind of Hindu traditionalism, which many people have associated with Gandhi. Are these the three right framing categories? And if so, how does the third distinguish itself from number one and number two?
Ramachandra Guha Number two is Nehruvian Secularism? Number…
Milan Vaishnav Nehruvian secularism, Hindu nationalism, Hindu traditionalism.
Ramachandra Guha No, I think Gandhi was called, not Hindu traditionalism, he was called by Ashis Nandi, critical traditionalism. So, Nehruvian secularism, Hindu fundamentalism, and critical traditionalism, not Hindu traditionalism, critical because of his critical attitude towards caste and gender. I think that’s the frame for Gandhi, the phrase I use in the book, the accurate description of Gandhi's ideas on religion and faith is that he was a theological pluralist. You know, so we know pluralism of ideas and lifestyles and sexual practices. He was a theologically pluralist, he was Hindu but did not seek to impose his Hinduism on others. He was a Hindu who sought equal rights in India in Hindu-majority India for those who are not Hindus. He was a Hindu who was looking for fault lines within his own society. He was the Hindu who constantly caught in friendships with people of other faiths. His closest friend was a Christian priest, C.F. Andrews. His first preceptor was a Jain. We've talked about the association of Muslims. So, the phrase that I find most appropriate for understanding Gandhi's attitude to faith is theological pluralism. I mean, it's a slightly cumbersome phrase, but I think it's probably accurate.
Milan Vaishnav So, Ram, I mean, here you are publishing yet another book about Gandhi and putting it out in the world. And of course, we'll link to the book in the show notes so people can get their copy. The obvious question arises about whether you feel like Ram Guha's journey with Gandhi has come to an end or if there are still other aspects of Gandhi and Gandhian thinking that you have yet to fully explore and or investigate. And I'm curious how you're thinking about it.
Ramachandra Guha Well, it's not come to an end. And there are other aspects of Gandhian thinking, Gandhian legacies, controversies around Gandhi that have interested me that are not captured in the three books I've written about Gandhi. And I am certain that there will be a fourth book about Gandhi, it's very likely that there'll be a fifth. I hope the books four and five are distinct in some or many ways from books one, two, and three. I'll say no more. But they are well worked out in my mind, I've done the research. But just as I came to Gandhi after having written other books, you mentioned India after Gandhi, I also worked on the environment and so on. And so, I might take a break from Gandhi. I mean, the next thing I publish or the next and the next to next thing published on Gandhi will probably be on different topics. But if I live long enough, I have at least two more books to write on.
Milan Vaishnav Well, amen to that. We will look forward to books four and five on Gandhi and, of course, having you back to talk about them. My guest on the show this week is the historian Ramachandra Guha. His latest book is called Arguments with Gandhi. It's a terrific intellectual exploration of debates around and with Gandhi on violence, justice, faith, and progress. It's not only a fascinating read, which questions a lot of what you may I've been told about Gandhi, but its also a very accessible read, which is not something that you always expect with intellectual history. Ram, thank you so much for taking the time.
Ramachandra Guha Thank you. Thank you, Milan. Always lovely to be here.