Source: Getty
testimony

Is the Nuclear Non-proliferation Regime in crisis? If so, why? Are there remedies?

The international community should stand back and reflect on the lessons learned from the International Atomic Energy Agency's (IAEA) experience in implementing safeguards over the last decade, particularly in North Korea and Iran. Such review and reflection suggests that just when safeguards are getting better, the political will to use them effectively seems to be waning.

by Pierre Goldschmidt
published by
Charlottesville Committee on Foreign Relations Speech
 on May 11, 2006

Source: Charlottesville Committee on Foreign Relations Speech

INTRODUCTION

Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-1859) stated: "In politics what is often most difficult to understand and appraise is what is taking place under our eyes."

De Tocqueville's insight suggests that it would be wise for the international community to stand back and to reflect on the lessons that should be learned from the International Atomic Energy Agency's (IAEA) experience in implementing safeguards over the last decade, particularly in North Korea and Iran. Such review and reflection will suggest that, ironically, just when safeguards are getting better, the political will to use them effectively seems to be waning.

This paper will explore how safeguards have gotten better, what lessons can be gleaned from the IAEA's experience over the last decade, and how the international community can address the problems that have arisen in the past few years.

Click here to access the full text of the speech (PDF).
 

Nuclear PolicyNuclear EnergyNorth AmericaUnited StatesMiddle EastIranIraqSouth AsiaIndiaPakistanSouth KoreaCaucasusRussiaUnited Kingdom
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.

More work from Carnegie

  • collection
    Korean Peninsula

    North Korea’s evolving nuclear arsenal presents a complex security challenge. What can states and international organizations do to reduce immediate nuclear risks while planning for a longer term disarmament process?

  • commentary
    Sada
    Unpunished: The Politics of Impunity in Yemen

    Attacks on journalists in Yemen have escalated at an alarming pace since the onset of the war in 2014. As a result of the continued impunity of perpetrators, restrictions on freedom of expression have increased.

    • Ismael Alaghbari
  • collection
    U.S. Nuclear Policy

    The United States faces a series of critically important decisions on nuclear procurement, posture, and declaratory policy. Which policies will best ensure effective deterrence while minimizing the risks of escalation and arms racing?

  • two suited men who are facing the camera and talking to sailors with their backs to the camera on a ship
    commentary
    Emissary
    NATO’s Northeast Countries Have a Template for Europe’s New Security Reality

    Ramping up the Joint Expeditionary Force would contribute to European security and prepare the continent for a second Trump administration.

  • commentary
    Strategic Europe
    Europe’s Wake-Up Call for Tech Leadership

    Europe’s digital future cannot hinge on Washington’s whims or the outcome of elections every four years. To achieve a level of technological autonomy, Europe needs targeted investments and responsible innovation in key sectors.