• Research
  • Emissary
  • About
  • Experts
Carnegie Global logoCarnegie lettermark logo
DemocracyIran
  • Donate
{
  "authors": [
    "C. Raja Mohan"
  ],
  "type": "legacyinthemedia",
  "centerAffiliationAll": "dc",
  "centers": [
    "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace",
    "Carnegie India"
  ],
  "collections": [],
  "englishNewsletterAll": "ctw",
  "nonEnglishNewsletterAll": "",
  "primaryCenter": "Carnegie India",
  "programAffiliation": "SAP",
  "programs": [
    "South Asia"
  ],
  "projects": [],
  "regions": [
    "South Asia",
    "India"
  ],
  "topics": [
    "Security",
    "Military",
    "Foreign Policy"
  ]
}

Source: Getty

In The Media
Carnegie India

Missing Shangri-La

Bureaucratic and political holdups in India’s defense ministry have undermined New Delhi’s ties with its neighbors.

Link Copied
By C. Raja Mohan
Published on Jun 5, 2013
Program mobile hero image

Program

South Asia

The South Asia Program informs policy debates relating to the region’s security, economy, and political development. From strategic competition in the Indo-Pacific to India’s internal dynamics and U.S. engagement with the region, the program offers in-depth, rigorous research and analysis on South Asia’s most critical challenges.

Learn More

Source: Indian Express

"Eighty per cent of success," Woody Allen famously said, is just "showing up." India's longest serving defense minister, A.K. Antony, however, was a "no-show" at Asia's leading annual defense forum, the Shangri-La Dialogue (SLD) in Singapore last week.

As Asia becomes the cockpit of great power rivalry and regional conflict, the SLD, organized by the International Institute of Strategic Studies, has become the vehicle for formal and informal consultations between the region's top defense policymakers. Running for more than a decade, with the support of the Singapore government, the SLD attracts defense ministers from all major countries in the region; China, which was initially opposed to the forum, now sends a very impressive delegation.

The MoD's approach to the SLD has been unprofessional, to say the least. Personal whims rather than a careful consideration of India's interests seem to define New Delhi's decisions. Consider the fact that Antony headed out to Singapore en route to Australia and Thailand on Monday. But he could not schedule participation in the SLD on the weekend that preceded it.

While the SLD has become a regular fixture on the calendar of all Asian defense ministries—it takes place on the last weekend of May—the MoD never makes up its mind until the very last minute on who might represent the country. In a very lucky year Antony might agree, with great reluctance, to fetch up in Singapore. More often than not, it is the junior minister in the MoD who is dispatched; sometimes it is the National Security Adviser, Shivshankar Menon. This year, Admiral D.K. Joshi, the Chief of Naval Staff, was the top Indian delegate to the SLD.

Representation at less than the cabinet level, however, is a protocol handicap when it comes to speaking slots and meetings on the margins of the conference. At this year's SLD, there was no Indian speaker in the prestigious plenary sessions.

Antony, the minister, might be excused for not seeing the salience of India's defense diplomacy. But shouldn't the MoD bureaucrats be tendering professional advice rather than pandering to the minister's predilections? Why is it so hard for the MoD to decide on sending a substantive delegation led by the defense minister every year to the Shangri-La Dialogue, and touch base with all the Asian security establishments that are so eagerly seeking engagement with India?

Our foreign office can get the prime minister to sign up high-sounding declarations on the Look East policy and proclaim "strategic partnerships" with ASEAN nations. But when our southeast Asian interlocutors turn to the MoD for follow-up, they run into a brick wall.

In track-two interactions, ASEAN policymakers vent their frustration in dealing with the MoD—at the bilateral as well as the multilateral level. Many bilateral agreements with ASEAN countries on defence cooperation are languishing because of the MoD's inability to implement them.

Worse still, the MoD is also very suspicious that our armed forces are keen to develop deeper interaction with Asian militaries and the MEA, which recognizes defense diplomacy as a new quiver in its armory.

At a time when China and the United States have dramatically stepped up their defense diplomacy in Asia, the MoD seems out for lunch and a siesta. At the SLD last week, U.S. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel invited all the ASEAN defense ministers for an interaction in Hawaii next year. China's People's Liberation Army has been engaging the ASEAN defense establishments, collectively, for many years.

No one expects the MoD's current leadership—both political and bureaucratic—to take bold new initiatives towards ASEAN. What surprises southeast Asia is the passive incoherence of the MoD's participation in the various defiance forums of ASEAN—neither ready to lead nor willing to respond.

Some tend to dress-up the MoD's feckless defense diplomacy as a deeply felt assertion of India's "strategic autonomy." Nice try. The real problem is the lack of political will in Delhi to take defense diplomacy in Asia seriously.

To be fair, Antony has occasionally referred to India's role as a "net security provider" in the Indian Ocean and beyond. What Antony needs is a strong institutional base in the MoD that can effectively collaborate with the armed forces and the foreign office and facilitate India's emergence as a valuable security partner for friendly Asian nations.

This article originally appeared in the Indian Express.

About the Author

C. Raja Mohan

Former Nonresident Senior Fellow, Carnegie India

A leading analyst of India’s foreign policy, Mohan is also an expert on South Asian security, great-power relations in Asia, and arms control.

    Recent Work

  • Article
    Deepening the India-France Maritime Partnership

      C. Raja Mohan, Darshana M. Baruah

  • Commentary
    Shanghai Cooperation Organization at Crossroads: Views From Moscow, Beijing and New Delhi
      • Alexander Gabuev
      • +1

      Alexander Gabuev, Paul Haenle, C. Raja Mohan, …

C. Raja Mohan
Former Nonresident Senior Fellow, Carnegie India
SecurityMilitaryForeign PolicySouth AsiaIndia

Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.

More Work from Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

  • Commentary
    Strategic Europe
    How Realistic Is Peace in Ukraine?

    Russia’s maximalist demands are preventing any serious attempt at ending the war in Ukraine. To make peace a realistic prospect, Putin must recognize that diplomacy is a two-way street.

      Kadri Liik

  • Jordanian Armed Forces, U.S. Army and U.S. Marine Corps forces and other international forces conduct a combined Arms Live Fire Exercise that practices the synchronization of tactical maneuvers, fire support assets and air power, during the Eager Lion 2024 exercise on May 23, 2024 in the desert near Azraq, Jordan
    Paper
    American Power in MENA: Depleted and Adrift

    An overreliance on coercive military action has moved the United States further from its goals in the Middle East and North Africa.

      Amr Hamzawy, Kathryn Selfe

  • Commentary
    Carnegie Politika
    Putin Is Using the Ukraine Peace Talks to Reshape Europe

    The concrete goal of an end to the hostilities in Ukraine has been replaced by a host of vague Russian demands concerning a range of issues and regions.

      Alexander Baunov

  • Commentary
    Diwan
    When the Soldiers Say Stop

    A recent dispute in Lebanon between a politician and the army commander over Hezbollah’s weapons has deeper roots.

      Michael Young

  • Robotic arms at an EV manufacturing plant working on a battery assembly
    Commentary
    Emissary
    To Keep Its Second Place in the Global Battery Race, Seoul Needs More Teammates

    In an increasingly competitive landscape, Seoul should expand its current partnership with Washington and deepen ties with Brussels and New Delhi.

      • Milo McBride

      Darcie Draudt-Véjares, Milo McBride

Get more news and analysis from
Carnegie This Week
Carnegie global logo, stacked
1779 Massachusetts Avenue NWWashington, DC, 20036-2103Phone: 202 483 7600
  • Research
  • Emissary
  • About
  • Experts
  • Donate
  • Programs
  • Events
  • Blogs
  • Podcasts
  • Contact
  • Annual Reports
  • Careers
  • Privacy
  • For Media
  • Government Resources
Get more news and analysis from
Carnegie This Week
© 2026 Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. All rights reserved.