Alexey Malashenko
{
"authors": [
"Alexey Malashenko"
],
"type": "commentary",
"centerAffiliationAll": "",
"centers": [
"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace",
"Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center"
],
"collections": [],
"englishNewsletterAll": "",
"nonEnglishNewsletterAll": "",
"primaryCenter": "Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center",
"programAffiliation": "",
"programs": [],
"projects": [],
"regions": [
"Russia",
"Western Europe",
"France"
],
"topics": [
"Security",
"Civil Society",
"Religion",
"Economy"
]
}Source: Getty
What the Anti-Terrorist Rally Demonstrated
An optimal model for the painless existence of Muslims in an alien cultural and religious environment has not yet been found and is unlikely to appear in the near future. In essence, Europe is dealing with a conflict of identities, which continues to increase.
The string of terrorist attacks in France—the killing of twelve staff members at the magazine Charlie Hebdo on January 7 and the murder of four hostages at a kosher grocery store on January 9—has drawn an amazingly impressive response. A million and a half marchers took to the streets in Paris alone, and up to 5 million people took part in rallies across France. Almost 60 heads of state showed up for the Paris march. Civil society joined forces with politicians, which does not happen all that often.
This reaction from Europeans should make a strong impression on Muslims. Most of them also oppose extremism, which disrupts the normal course of their lives, exacerbates difficulties adapting to European realities, and creates an air of intolerance. Islam is being increasingly judged based on the actions of religious extremists. Acts of terrorism similar to the ones in Paris tend to isolate Muslims from the rest of society.
One of the difficulties facing the Muslim community is adjusting to the culture of their new home. Unfortunately, the record reflects the fact that an optimal model for the painless existence of Muslims in an alien cultural and religious environment has not yet been found and is unlikely to appear in the near future. Assimilation is all but impossible; it is evident that adaptation has been very problematic, and multiculturalism, in which many put a lot of stock, has effectively failed. In essence, Europe is dealing with a conflict of identities, which continues to increase.
The controversy surrounding cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad represents a clear and dangerous illustration of this development. It is highly unlikely that a compromise on this particular subject will ever be reached. The fact that many media outlets reprinted the cartoons as a token of solidarity with their fallen colleagues can be interpreted as a display of their commitment to freedom of expression even at risk to their lives, but it is also a challenge to Muslims, a provocation.
In this context, Russia’s position is quite interesting. On the one hand, the Kremlin unequivocally condemned the terrorist attacks—in fact, nothing short of that could have been expected. On the other hand, the Russian foreign minister rather than the president represented the country at the anti-terrorism rally (the Ukrainian impasse played a role here). In a sense, the Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov, who effectively dons the hat of a federal-level politician, has expressed Moscow’s views on events in France with his condemnation of the Mohammad cartoons. The official Russian propaganda machine has frequently assailed the Western media and Western society as a whole for its “excessive freedoms” that lead to “total permissiveness.” In fact, in this, Russian and Islamic ideologues find themselves in agreement.
About the Author
Former Scholar in Residence, Religion, Society, and Security Program
Malashenko is a former chair of the Carnegie Moscow Center’s Religion, Society, and Security Program.
- What Will Uzbekistan’s New President Do?Commentary
- Preserving the Calm in Russia’s Muslim CommunityCommentary
Alexey Malashenko
Recent Work
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.
More Work from Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
- "Digger" May Be the Most Influential Climate Movie YetCommentary
Despite its flop at the box office, the film raises important questions for the climate community to answer.
Leonardo Martinez-Diaz
- Stalled at the Front, Russia Seeks to Undermine Ukraine’s Economic CapacityCommentary
Russian strikes are weakening the economy sustaining Ukraine’s war effort. Closing the growing funding gap will require more European support and politically contentious reforms in Kyiv.
Balázs Jarábik
- The Scramble for Europe. Russia, China, and Turkey Challenging Regional OrderBook
Europe is facing rising populism internally as well as external pressures from Russia, China, Turkey, and the United States.
Dimitar Bechev
- Europe’s Tide of Citizen Assemblies: Unsung Success or Anticlimax?Article
A notable degree of participative democracy has firmly arrived in Europe. But to have more far-reaching impact, democratic deliberation needs to move into a radically new phase.
Richard Youngs
- Sri Lanka’s Economic and Geopolitical Balancing ActArticle
Economic recovery has brought Sri Lanka a modicum of stability, but domestic strains and great-power rivalry could test how long it lasts.
Avinash Paliwal