In the spring of 1919, as the world’s major powers descended on Versailles to negotiate peace after World War I, President Woodrow Wilson was in bed with the flu. At a moment when, as Wilson’s doctor put it, “the whole of civilization seemed to be in the balance,” a horrific influenza pandemic cast a shadow over the prospect of a new order.
A century later, we find ourselves again crippled by a pandemic during another of those rare plastic moments in world affairs—a perfect storm of major shifts in the balance of power and massive political, economic, technological and environmental transformations. Great-power rivalry is back; China has risen, and America’s old dominance has been spent. The world’s economic and military center of gravity is shifting from West to East. A technological revolution is upending how we live, work and fight. Tensions are growing between open and closed societies, with nationalism and authoritarianism resurgent and democracy seemingly in reverse. The tailwinds of globalization have transformed into powerful headwinds, even as climate change looms as an existential threat.
The storm has been gathering for some time, and America’s post-Cold War missteps quickened the landfall. Today’s coronavirus pandemic will further intensify the storm’s severity, with terrible human and economic costs. It will be a painful accelerant—exposing our vulnerabilities and magnifying the challenge of navigating a crowded, complicated and competitive international landscape.
The crisis will reinforce cocky convictions—from Moscow to Beijing—about the demise of a “liberal international order.” It will spur strongmen to grip even tighter, bolstered by new surveillance technologies. Narrow-minded nationalists will fan the flames of xenophobia. Key Western democracies, already infected by paralytic politics and constipated governance, will see their crisis of self-confidence deepen.
Connectivity will be seen as a weakness, not a strength, dealing another blow to the fragile European project. The Middle East and Africa, already burdened by conflicts and pathologies, will be exposed to even more troubles. The U.N. and other international institutions, long groaning and creaking, will start to crack, as will the alliances that have bolstered American security. Global humanitarian crises will worsen, their toll compounded by the virus and an increasingly under-resourced and distracted global response.
But shocks like this awful pandemic can clarify as well as accelerate. With brutal impact, they give us a chance to diagnose our challenges with clear eyes. The test for American statesmanship will be to resist the temptation to pull up the drawbridges and retreat, as well as the illusion that we can restore the easy dominance we once enjoyed.
The test for American statesmanship will be to resist the temptation to pull up the drawbridges and retreat.
We cannot resurrect the uniquely commanding positions that helped American statesmen in the administrations led by Harry Truman and George H.W. Bush shape similar plastic moments over the past century. But we can revive their model of character, vision and discipline in applying American power. We can rebuild America’s democratic example and rekindle the confidence of our allies and the respect of our rivals. Even in this most difficult of moments, we have a rare opening to recover a sense of national purpose and enlightened self-interest and to help Americans—and the world—find shelter from the storm.
This article was originally published by the Wall Street Journal.
Comments(1)
It is a telling mistake to believe that Russia and China are somehow not a significant part of the Liberal International Order. Liberalism is now globally supreme and China is its workshop, while Russia remains a very important gas station. Liberalism is not democracy. It is a monolithic structure of materialist growth that knows no bounds, as it believes that humanity is somehow separate from nature. America long ago became a nation of consumers not citizens. But consumption is hardly progress, and as our current global pandemic shows (climate change, as well) nature always has the last word. Yet Liberalism demands an ever growing monoculture; a bigger and bigger leviathan of conformity and material goods masquerading as progress, yet characterized by an overbearing centralization. The old republican concept of virtue within the common good of community has been erased by the iron logic of laissez-faire and all those adherents of Adam Smith and Hamilton who followed. In the end, Montesquieu and the anti-federalists were prescient, size does indeed matter. And any state that forms intricate economic bonds with a massive totalitarian dictatorship can hardly be called a republic. Yet, this is where our post-Cold War foreign policy has taken us. The US political elite has acted as a subsidiary of its corporate overlords since the assassination of Lincoln. But it was Vladimir Lenin who most clearly understood the pecuniary avarice of those lords, when he surmised that they would sell the rope to their own hanging. And they have, geopolitically speaking, that is. In hindsight, everyone can now see that China won the Cold War. But where will the new consumer demand come from? That is, when America is broke and Trump's vanity can no longer spin out his myriad of excuses. The Democrats are hardly better with their "monopoly money" definitions of monetary policy and their penchant for dozens of trillions of newly minted "red ink". As if all problems can be solved by debt and taxes, and that the central government evn has the solutions. Depend on the rich; yet tax them to the hilt. This is hardly a strategy for successful capitalist growth leading to the correct balance with nature. The sad fact is that human growth has already reached its limits and we are already operating on borrowed time and money. It was Chief Seattle of the Suquamish People who understood the Liberal Order best when he stated: "The earth does not belong to us, we belong to the earth".
Comment Policy
Comments that include profanity, personal attacks, or other inappropriate material will be removed. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, steps will be taken to block users who violate any of the posting standards, terms of use, privacy policies, or any other policies governing this site. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.